News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by munificent on Saturday January 23, 2021 @08:49PM (#25888162)
In order to keep woodworking finishes from drying in the can, many woodworkers displace air in the can by dumping marbles in. You could probably do the same thing with a wine bottle:

1. Drink as much as you want.

2. Pour small clean marbles into the bottle until the level of the wine is near the top again.

3. Put cork back in.

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by rsync on Saturday January 23, 2021 @10:11PM (#25888749)
Yes, this is very common in beer brewing and wine making - filling up headspace in primary fermenters with glass marbles.

I don't like the idea as I don't need a 14th thing to carefully sanitize. Instead, I just displace the headspace with CO2 and have had good success with that.

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by CoryMathews on Sunday January 24, 2021 @12:10PM (#25893638)
This is not at all common in beer brewing. I cannot speak for the wine world but most of them have variable height lids.

No brewery would ever put glass marbles into a primary fermenter. As a professional brewer we routinely try to have the beer touch as few items as possible, post chill, due to sanitation risks. Not only would marbles be a nightmare to sanitize (tiny chips or cracks would not be properly sanitized), its a logistical nightmare to later get them out to clean the tank. Tanks are cleaned in place with a pump and spray ball method without ever opening the tank. Getting excessive hops out is enough work much less marbles.

Breweries purge any air out of a tank with Co2 before filling, for multiple reasons, but since Co2 is heavier than air it will settle on top of the unfermented wort as it is gently transferred into the fermentation tank thus removing the need for any kind of marbles or headspace reduction.

A second major reason this would not be done is that when beer ferments it needs extra headspace as the yeast in an ale ferments on top of the beer. A hefeweizen will routinely create a yeast layer about 10-15% of the height on top of the liquid. So if this space was blocked it would be forced out the top, which for most modern breweries would create a large mess into the floor drains and lead to the yeast count being too low reuse.

On the flip side I would be very interested to know of a brewery doing this and why.

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by rsync on Sunday January 24, 2021 @03:02PM (#25895315)
Sorry - I am speaking specifically of the home brewing community. You can see them using, and recommending, glass marbles / glass balls all the time.

Yes, I cannot imagine this method being used in serious retail production.

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by im3w1l on Sunday January 24, 2021 @06:59AM (#25891346)
What would happen if you didn't carefully sanitize it? What would start growing?
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by rwmj on Sunday January 24, 2021 @09:47AM (#25892423)
Air and surfaces are filled with random mould spores and bacteria. If they touch your beverage (which is by definition full of stuff that mould loves, because yeast is a mould) then they will grow, causing off-flavours or even poisons. You prevent this by sanitising everything, and making sure that any headspace is filled with either carbon dioxide or sulphur dioxide. CO2 is produced naturally by fermentation and because it's heavier than air it settles in the headspace displacing oxygen (moulds need oxygen to reproduce). Sulphur dioxide can be added using sterilising tablets (Campden tablets). Other techniques are to reduce the headspace by adding more liquid, or marbles, apparently, and using an airlock to stop air entering.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by CoryMathews on Monday January 25, 2021 @08:26AM (#25902845)
"causing off-flavours or even poisons. "

There is nothing that can grow during fermentation in beer or wine that will hurt you. It will just taste terrible, or unplanned.

In lower abv fermentation such as kombucha or fermented vegetables. Molds can be a risk if the starting medium is not low enough ph, or high enough salinity.

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by rwmj on Monday January 25, 2021 @11:50AM (#25905394)
Something like aspergillus flavus could poison you, although you'd notice that because it would be clearly visible as a green mould with a terrible smell & taste. I homebrew myself and agree that poisoning from ordinary brewing (not distillation) is incredibly unlikely.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by odonnellryan on Saturday January 23, 2021 @10:27PM (#25888860)
I'm sure co2 works great, but much cheaper is a manual vacuum device.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by alasdair_ on Sunday January 24, 2021 @02:27AM (#25890089)
The article strongly implies these devices don’t work at all in practice.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by 0-_-0 on Sunday January 24, 2021 @05:03AM (#25890777)
They work abolutely amazing for me, if you leave it for a while the wine often tastes much better. The vacuum appears to produce a special kind of decanting. (Technically, it's more like 0.5 atmospheres)
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by stjohnswarts on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:35AM (#25893313)
the ones like Eto work because they displace air which is necessary for the bacteria to turn the alcohol to vinegar. Well actually slow it down. I can confirm the Eto works okay and wine keeps pretty well for a week or so. and yeah I did a side by side with a couple of $10 wines of the same variety after two weeks one was nasty and the other was still drinkable and not gone completely off by then.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by pacaro on Saturday January 23, 2021 @09:24PM (#25888410)
This feels like a surprisingly obvious idea

Printmakers sometimes float a layer of water on top of partially used ink to stop it polymerizing. I suspect that floating a layer of oil on top of wine might have some undesirable side effects

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by munificent on Monday January 25, 2021 @12:27PM (#25905987)
> I suspect that floating a layer of oil on top of wine might have some undesirable side effects

I love starting a meal with a refreshing glass of Caprese salad dressing.

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by im3w1l on Sunday January 24, 2021 @07:01AM (#25891353)
I guess the big issue with marbles is that it gets progressively more annoying the less wine you have left. And with little left, it wont even be possible to get the level to the top because of all the space between the marbles.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by kzrdude on Sunday January 24, 2021 @12:38PM (#25893888)
Good point.

Isn't there an even more obvious idea though - use a smaller bottle or a vessel that can be shrunk to the right volume?

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by munificent on Sunday January 24, 2021 @11:28PM (#25899126)
Zip-Loc bag for the win.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by birken on Sunday January 24, 2021 @02:34AM (#25890124)
Woodworkers also commonly use argon, most often via the product "Bloxygen" which is just canned argon.

I've used displacement, vacuum sealing, CO2 via my breath and argon. Argon works the best and is the easiest.

Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by cycrutchfield on Sunday January 24, 2021 @01:39PM (#25894473)
Probably a cleaner option is to just decant your wine into a smaller container, such as a half bottle (375 ml) or some Boston rounds.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by codesnik on Saturday January 23, 2021 @10:07PM (#25888721)
I have no idea what marbles are made of, but if they are even remotely similar to actual marble and not, say, glass, I'm sure it'll react with acid in the wine.
Re:How long does a bottle of wine last after it is opened? by matt-attack on Sunday January 24, 2021 @01:07AM (#25889754)
Marbles are made of glass. Completely inert in this context.