News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by gaius on Monday July 28, 2008 @02:49AM (#258847)
But Jo(e) User doesn't really care about that, he or she cares about search results. If (and admittedly this is unproven) Google can deliver better search results by logging and analyzing search activity to personalize results, then Cuil is already at a disadvantage.
Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by marcus on Monday July 28, 2008 @04:44AM (#258900)
How can you call it unproven? When I google for Python I get stuff related to programming because of my search history, when a zoologist looks for Pythons he'll see stuff related to snakes.
Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by gaius on Monday July 28, 2008 @06:52AM (#258957)
Because I don't know what algorithms Cuil are using, I can't say at this stage if they are able to deliver better search results than Google without personalization. Perhaps they're better at contextualization for example, and don't need to know what you did last time.

I'm a Python programmer too and the first link I get from Google for 'python' is a Wikipedia article on the Delphic Oracle... Admittedly I have often searched for content relating to Oracle databases!

Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by ashleyw on Monday July 28, 2008 @07:39AM (#258982)
Weird, I've searched python once or twice (never really used it) in the past, and don't get a Wikipedia article first, I get http://www.python.org, then the whole page is filled with python (programming) results.

I've never really thought about this, but I'm kinda glad Google logs my results, it helps me out tons by giving me results I want. Plus thier motto is "Don't be Evil"...

Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by marcus on Monday July 28, 2008 @07:24AM (#258972)
Context is always helpful and obviously should be used in addition to personal history and even override it, but if the query has little context, the only context you can get is from the users historical data.

Personalization doesn't guarantee better results but it obviously improves results.

Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by mattjung on Tuesday July 29, 2008 @12:04PM (#260671)
Historical data may as well be misleading because the profile of a user is not "static", simply because there's a human being behind it (and sometimes even more than one, but that's another story). His personal and professional environment, his wishes and necessities, the context of his life may change from one day to the other. The assumption that the past queries of a user will improve the results of his current queries is at least questionable (especially for former programmers that start selling reptiles...)
Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by gaius on Monday July 28, 2008 @07:39AM (#258983)
I'm not saying that's not true, just that Cuil must believe that they don't need it, and it's too soon to see if they're right.

I do most of my searches on www.msdewey.com anyway :-)

Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by nailer on Monday July 28, 2008 @08:52AM (#259013)
I search for python pretty regularly on Google. My recent, logged-in, searches for 'python gecko' resulted in a bunch of reptile sellers.
Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by jrockway on Monday July 28, 2008 @09:41AM (#259049)
I search for programming-related things, and all but two results (both videos) for "python gecko" are about Mozilla bindings for Python.

Basically, I am not upset that Google profiles me. I would get upset when my profile is admissible as evidence against me in court, but that's not up to Google. Let's not make searching the web difficult because our legal system is fucked up. Let's fix the legal system.

Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by nailer on Monday July 28, 2008 @08:30PM (#259851)
I think we're probably getting the same page - I get:

* YouTube - Leopard gecko and royal python eat mice!!

* FS: 2 captive-born Mali Uromastyx - via auction (gargoyle python gecko boa) Reptiles. ...

before I get:

* Re: [pyxpcom] Python web crawler using Gecko :: ASPN Mail Archive ...

I'd have thought, given my history, the reptile versions would come later.

Re:Ex-Google engineers debut 'Cuil' way to search by 13ren on Monday July 28, 2008 @01:27PM (#259293)
BTW: your comment comes up 6th on my google search for 'python gecko'.

When logged out, the search results are slightly differently ordered.