News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by asciilifeform on Thursday May 26, 2011 @12:46PM (#2588389)
If we're going to play "morality via contest of body counts"... A foolish game to play, but hey, why not. Good sportsmanship and all.

So:

The history of the New World.

Had enough? Is the "winner" of the murder-Olympics still so clear to you?

How about after adjusting the slaughter-count logarithmically to account for world population growth? (You can't kill people who have never lived yet.)

I hope that we both live long enough to read post-USA texts on American history. I'm sure they will make for at least as exciting an afternoon of reading as the now dime-a-dozen works on Russian atrocities.

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by guygurari on Thursday May 26, 2011 @01:55PM (#2588730)
You went after his first link but ignored the second one on collectivization which I think is more pertinent. At least with privatization the government, which represents the interests of the people, acts within its mandate: It sells assets that belong to the people. With collectivism the government is coercing citizens to give up property against their will. If anything, collectivism is theft.
Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by asciilifeform on Thursday May 26, 2011 @02:36PM (#2588912)
With collectivization, the government, assuming that it represents the interests of its people, is also acting within its mandate. Our difference of opinion appears to be that you believe a government which collectivizes property to be automatically illegitimate, and one which privatizes formerly collectivized property to be automatically legitimate. You define the act of nationalizing property to be one which leads to loss of legitimacy.

There are excellent reasons to believe that most Soviet citizens opposed privatization. In that case, the Western "democracies" lie through their teeth when they claim that "the will of the people was done."

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by guygurari on Thursday May 26, 2011 @03:16PM (#2589058)
> Our difference of opinion appears to be that you believe a government which collectivizes property to be automatically illegitimate, and one which privatizes formerly collectivized property to be automatically legitimate. You define the act of nationalizing property to be one which leads to loss of legitimacy.

I'm not thinking in such absolutes. Any government must balance individual rights against society's interests. Sometimes collectivization is reasonable. However, collectivization involves coercion and therefore should be employed only in extreme cases.

On the other hand, privatization is a deal between two willing and legitimate parties, with no coercion involved. Specifically the government is entrusted by the people to manage its assets, and selling an asset is a legitimate transaction.

The problems with privatization lie with the execution rather than the idea. Many governments don't properly represent the interests of the people in such transactions, either because of incompetence or because of corruption. But with governments' conduct, incompetence and corruption seem to be the rule rather than the exception.

> There are excellent reasons to believe that most Soviet citizens opposed privatization. In that case, the Western "democracies" lie through their teeth when they claim that "the will of the people was done."

In representative democracies, what "most" citizens think about a specific government decision carries no weight. If the citizens are unhappy with the government, they can protest and they can vote to replace the government. But it is crucial that making unpopular decisions does not revoke the legitimacy of the government.

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by asciilifeform on Thursday May 26, 2011 @03:23PM (#2589082)
If the citizens are unhappy with the government, they can protest and they can vote to replace the government.

How much good does this do you once the government has sold off the national infrastructure (and perhaps even its own sovereign powers) to mafiosi, foreigners, and their agents?

Where can you vote for reversing the destruction of industries which took 70 years to build?

Where is the voting booth where you can go to vote against having had your popular culture murdered through vulgarization?

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by guygurari on Thursday May 26, 2011 @03:47PM (#2589154)
> How much good does this do you once the government has sold off the national infrastructure ...

It does a lot of good if you vote in a government that buys back said infrastructure. "Sold" does not equal "destroyed".

But let me address your more general point as I understand it. There is no system that will protect you from a government that makes terrible decisions that destroy the country. What is your solution? Don't allow the government to sell anything? That's like banning knives because knives can be used for murder. Or perhaps have a committee that decides what can be sold? Well the government is already such a committee.

The only "solution" I see is to decide the government owns everything, so nothing important can be sold by mistake. Well the evidence of the previous century suggests that this creates much worse problems than it solves. This system has been tried, and it failed.

Governments, and people in general, make terrible decisions. Some of them outright disastrous. The best you can hope for is a system that lets you minimize the damage. Today it seems that democracy and capitalism is the best combination we have for minimizing the pain inflicted by people upon themselves.

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by sbov on Thursday May 26, 2011 @07:20PM (#2589798)
And sometimes they make corrupt decisions. For instance, the example given in http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2589559 seems like an obvious example of corruption. There should absolutely be recourse for actions like this on both ends of the trade rather than just kicking the old guys out and having to buy it back for almost 10x what it was sold for.

If you buy stolen property, you're pretty much screwed. If you get sweet deals from corrupt officials, you should get screwed too.

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by chc on Thursday May 26, 2011 @03:03PM (#2589009)
I think you're misunderstanding.

The government represents the people as a whole.

If the people as a whole (i.e. the government) take something from one individual person, that could reasonably said to be theft. (It isn't necessarily theft, but it's not an unreasonable viewpoint.)

If the people as a whole (i.e. the government) sell something they own to one individual person, that cannot be theft. The nation cannot rob itself.

That's the distinction being drawn here.

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by asciilifeform on Thursday May 26, 2011 @03:13PM (#2589041)
If the people as a whole (i.e. the government) sell something they own to one individual person, that cannot be theft. The nation cannot rob itself.

Jesuitry.

If the US Congress sells its entire collective political power to Warren Buffett, who then becomes Fuhrer, nothing has been stolen from anyone?

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by lupatus on Thursday May 26, 2011 @09:48PM (#2590155)
Your civics is weak.

If Buffett bought the Congress, he would also need to buy the Judiciary and the Executive branches before he would have the power of a "Fuhrer".

Furthermore, the states could then revoke their consent to be governed by the Federal Government, just as they have revoked their consent to by governed by other authorities in the past (see the American Revolution, the Articles of Confederation, and the Confederate States of America).

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by asciilifeform on Thursday May 26, 2011 @10:24PM (#2590226)
Your civics is weak... he would also need to buy the Judiciary and the Executive branches

In practice, owning the legislature would probably suffice. There are provisions for a Congressionally-declared state of martial law.

Confederate States of America

This last one is a good guide to what will happen if a state were to "revoke its consent to be governed."

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by philwelch on Monday May 30, 2011 @02:37AM (#2598692)
"There are provisions for a Congressionally-declared state of martial law."

Where? I've read the entire Constitution and didn't find anything of the kind. And amending the Constitution requires the approval of 3/4 of the state legislatures.

Re:1 in 6 Russian entrepreneurs are in jail, 1 in 3 prisoner... by philwelch on Friday May 27, 2011 @02:03PM (#2592432)
Clearly, smallpox is more evil than communism.