News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by geuis on Monday July 28, 2008 @02:07AM (#258828)
I have a personal litmus test for new search engines - a vanity search on myself. I know my own content across the web better than anyone else's. By far, Google still rates far and above for returning the fullest and most pertinent set of results than any others. Cuil fails at this.

More generally, I compared common searches I do regularly relating to things like "javascript framework" and "css" and the results were poor.

Its not only about who has the biggest index. Its about retrieving the most relevant data from that index.

To be more crude, its not about the size of your <guess>, its about how you use it.

Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by babul on Monday July 28, 2008 @07:05AM (#258963)
Google has had a lot of time and resource to index your content. So it is not a fair compariosn yet. Give Cuil time to develop/index and then see the results.

On a side note, Cuil takes forever to load compared to Google, and search results aside, that is a major issue they need to address asap.

Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by TFrancis on Monday July 28, 2008 @01:35PM (#259305)
I don't think we ought to excuse Cuil and provide them more time before we judge the search engine. They've had all the time they needed and put out a press release saying so.
Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by swombat on Monday July 28, 2008 @08:22AM (#258999)
Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by wheels on Monday July 28, 2008 @05:18AM (#258923)
Same litmus test, got nothing. Tried a couple of other topics I know well, results weren't particularly good. The presentation is moderately interesting though.
Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by axod on Monday July 28, 2008 @06:19AM (#258943)
Interesting, yes, but I don't think a column layout works for a list of search results. It's much harder to scan.
Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by wheels on Monday July 28, 2008 @06:43AM (#258952)
I didn't mean the layout so much as that the description of the hit doesn't necessarily come from the text of the page. For instance, the description of kde.org is pulled out of Wikipedia. I'm not sure that approach works, but I think it's an interesting path to flesh out.
Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by run4yourlives on Monday July 28, 2008 @02:00PM (#259348)
Hah, I did the same thing, with the same results.

I'm also not impressed with the 3 column results page...a quick list of pages is much better for me.

Re:Cuil Launches -- Can This Search Start-Up Really Best Goo... by davidw on Monday July 28, 2008 @05:09AM (#258916)
They appear to have fiddled with something. I got no results earlier, but now I do, and while they're not great, it's much better than nothing.