Re:About Linkrot: Proportion of Working Links on Pinboard.in...
by fhars on Thursday May 26, 2011 @12:22PM
(#2588276)
Given that the data for the first few years result from a small number of pages, the graph doesn't allow to reliably distinguish between both interpretations, and his (and your) interpretation is not really justified. If you look just at the complete, reliable years (links from 2000 to 2010), the graph looks convex, just like you'd expect for exponential decay but not for linear decay. So while the first interpratation is probably intended by the author, I'd say he is overstating his case and is most probably wrong.
Re:About Linkrot: Proportion of Working Links on Pinboard.in...
by minimax on Thursday May 26, 2011 @03:54PM
(#2589170)
With that decay rate, the difference between exponential and linear decay is going to be tough to pick out just by looking at the graph.
http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=plot+e^%28x*ln%28.75%29...
edit: fixed decay constant
Re:About Linkrot: Proportion of Working Links on Pinboard.in...
by fhars on Thursday May 26, 2011 @04:33PM
(#2589338)
Yes, indeed. That is a nice graph, and in absence of a mechanism that would explain why no link can last longer than 28 years it should quite convincingly show that linear decay has not been established.
1. Every 7 years, 25% of the original links are lost: in 14 years half are working, and in 28 years you have approximately 0% of your links working. This is a steady, linear rate which does not have a half life.
2. Every 7 years, 25% of the remaining links are lost: in 7 years 75% are working, in 14 years 0.75^2 = 56% of the links are still working, and in 28 years 31.6% are working. This is exponential decay, which has a half-life and is contradictory.
From looking at the data, and from the explicitness with which he states that the decay is linear, I'd conclude that the former is true. It would be hard to make a case for the later.