News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by jasonlotito on Thursday May 26, 2011 @08:25AM (#2587453)
* Requires user interaction, so it doesn't count.

* Doesn't work if you aren't an admin.

* The OS is just installing what the user agreed to install.

Seems like Mac users are regurgitating Windows users' excuses from years ago.

It's a problem. Rather than make excuses, we should be expecting Apple and others to be actively working toward a solution.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by mahrain on Thursday May 26, 2011 @10:15AM (#2587783)
If I trick a GNU/Linux or UNIX user into running a "sudo rm -rf /" command and entering a password, did I create malware?
Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by tincholio on Thursday May 26, 2011 @12:18PM (#2588254)
No, modern rm implementations disallow that by default. You need to override it with a switch.
Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by bxr on Thursday May 26, 2011 @11:13AM (#2588006)
No, you didn't create software, but you effectively distributed a trojan.
Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by rbanffy on Thursday May 26, 2011 @10:12AM (#2587766)
So, you expect the operating system do disobey the user when it determines the user actions could be harmful?

If I tell my machine to do something, I want it to carry my orders.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by jasonlotito on Thursday May 26, 2011 @11:45AM (#2588143)
These are the same arguments Windows users used for years, and Linux and Mac users mocked them for it.

Regardless, you've presented a false dichotomy. That the only way to combat the risk is to prevent users from using their operating system as they see fit. That's not what I suggested, at all, and trying to frame an argument around it is dishonest.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by rbanffy on Thursday May 26, 2011 @11:57AM (#2588180)
Nothing will protect a computer from a determined user. The OS may even warn the user the action he is about to take can harm the computer, but the decision rests with the user.

What you can do is to keep ZFS-like file snapshots and allow the user to return to a moment in time previous to the infection.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by jasonlotito on Thursday May 26, 2011 @02:24PM (#2588870)
> Nothing will protect a computer from a determined user.

But their are numerous things you can do to protect a computer from your average user. Not doing these things because of exceptions is wrong.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by rbanffy on Thursday May 26, 2011 @05:02PM (#2589426)
I think we would be more productive if we focused our energy on educating the users instead of disobeying them.
Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by jasonlotito on Thursday May 26, 2011 @08:08PM (#2589915)
Abstinence-only eduction v.s education and protection. Right. Good policy.
Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by rbanffy on Thursday May 26, 2011 @08:31PM (#2589976)
I never said protection should be abandoned. I said education is more important because it allows users to use protective measures correctly.

And may render a lot of protective measures unnecessary.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by jasonlotito on Friday May 27, 2011 @09:16AM (#2591319)
> I never said protection should be abandoned.

It didn't sound like it.

Education is great. However, no amount of education will remove the need for real protections. This doesn't mean you disobey a you keep trying to suggest.

Look to the real world of examples. Education doesn't trump protection. Take anything you need to pass a test for or need a license for. Their are still protections put into place to prevent abuse. Hunting license, gun license, driver's license. All have protections on top of education because people make mistakes.

Finally, quit trying to suggest that protection means it prevents a user from doing what they want. Again, it's a false dichotomy and continuously trying to argue it devalues any point you are trying to make.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by rbanffy on Friday May 27, 2011 @09:24AM (#2591344)
> it prevents a user from doing what they want

Have you ever seen a false positive report from an anti-malware application? I have.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by bxr on Thursday May 26, 2011 @11:18AM (#2588029)
>If I tell my machine to do something, I want it to carry my orders.

I downloaded this 'Free Screensaver Pack' and I want to run it! Who does this virus scanner think it is? Quit telling me that its a bad idea and just goddamn do what I want you to.

If bad software exists I don't want my computer to warn me that it might be a bad idea to run it, I'd rather apple just creates a walled garden so I can don't even have the option to command my computer to do something bad.

Re:Mac malware evolves to no longer require users to enter t... by jasonlotito on Thursday May 26, 2011 @11:52AM (#2588162)
The problem is, people confuse prevention and warning. They complain about the exception, rather than the rule. Oddly, I see few complaints about browsing implementing phishing site protection and warnings about bad SSL certs, etc. After all, the browser should just take me to where I want to go and shouldn't get in the way. Right? =)