News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by mensetmanusman on Thursday January 21, 2021 @04:20PM (#25864414)
Apparently mostly facebook was used, not parler.
Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by klmadfejno on Thursday January 21, 2021 @04:25PM (#25864477)
Sure, maybe? Doesn't mean parler wasn't a toxic violent place. If you want to hold facebook to a higher standard, by all means, I agree.
Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by ojnabieoot on Thursday January 21, 2021 @04:43PM (#25864718)
Wait till you hear what us leftists want to do with Facebook!

I will say that my preferred solution to the problem of Facebook (nationalization and open criminal investigations into its leadership) actually raises serious constitutional issues. The Parler case really really doesn’t - it doesn’t even raise good philosophical issues about free speech, just a bunch of dumb arguments.

Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by duskwuff on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:12PM (#25865141)
You're conflating two different issues.

Some of the specific, concrete planning of violence may have taken place on Facebook. That doesn't appear to have been taking place as much on Parler -- possibly because it was less private -- but there was plenty of generally violent rhetoric on Parler, just less specific. "We should kill this person" (Parler) versus "Let's all meet up with our guns here" (Facebook).

Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by cma on Thursday January 21, 2021 @08:42PM (#25867178)
But what percentage of Facebook activity was used for it within getting moderated vs what percentage of parler activity?
Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by snoshy on Thursday January 21, 2021 @04:36PM (#25864613)
This smacks of whataboutism to me. No doubt Facebook hosted large amounts of this activity, but it does not negate the fact that Parler did so as well. Amazon's court filing detailed hundreds of incidents that they had given Parler months to fix.
Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by oh_sigh on Thursday January 21, 2021 @04:52PM (#25864892)
Crying "whataboutism" is just a meme-y way to shutdown claims of hypocrisy.

Husband: Two glasses of white wine in one night honey? You need to cut back for your health's sake

Wife: But dear, you drink a handle of vodka every night and have refused any attempts at intervention.

Husband: A-ha, classic whataboutism

edit: I'd love to respond to the people below me, but HN has decided that one post an hour is too much (despite having a 10 year old account and 4000+ karma)

Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by joshuamorton on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:06PM (#25865081)
Where's the hypocrisy? Should AWS drop facebook as a customer?

I don't think anyone is suggesting that Facebook is free of guilt, but there is evidence that Facebook does at least try to keep their site clean, and for the most part they do. Its certainly possible that Facebook had (in absolute terms) more violence and planning than Parler, but as a percentage of the overall content, it's much smaller.

This doesn't excuse Facebook, they can do better, but it isn't hypocritical to say "the group with 10% violent content that tacitly encourages it isn't okay, while the group with .1% violent content that actively innovates in trying to keep things clean is okay".

Of course, that's only true if FB is actively innovating, and, well, that's questionable (Yann Lecun has made some concerning statements about Facebook's role, or lack thereof, in radicalization).

Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by takeda on Thursday January 21, 2021 @07:04PM (#25866475)
Facebook and Twitter also have their own data centers, so it's not like AWS had to chose between Facebook, Parler or Twitter.
Re:Judge refuses to reinstate Parler after Amazon shut it down by snoshy on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:06PM (#25865066)
Facebook isn't even a party in this legal proceeding. The only ones are the court, Amazon, and Parler. Facebook could commit genocide tomorrow, and it would not affect this lawsuit.