Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game
by ab9 on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @10:50PM
(#2586426)
I'm understanding the term "hostile reading" as Card defines it in the above quotation. A hostile reader is one who approaches a book skeptically or is forced to read it (in the sense of being required to read it to complete a class). A hostile reading is what he does.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game
by sophacles on Thursday May 26, 2011 @10:44AM
(#2587891)
Wait... So if someone reads it voluntarily but skeptically it is somehow a hostile reading by the definition you cite? It seems to me you are selectively ignoring the part where he explicitly declares voluntary reading not hostile.
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game
by ab9 on Thursday May 26, 2011 @08:18PM
(#2589938)
No, Card does not explicitly declare that in the quotation I posted. (Did you mean elsewhere in his review?) He's saying: It's a hostile reading if it's skeptical rather than "with belief". It's also a hostile reading if it's forced rather than voluntary.
You probe his definition by asking, If someone reads it skeptically but voluntarily, does that count as hostile? That's a good question. I don't think we have enough information to answer it, because Card does not state how to weigh skepticism and forcedness against each other.