News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What my retraction taught me by bachmeier on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:06PM (#25863529)
You present a view of journals as an outlet for correct results. Realistically, that's not possible, and I wish more people accepted that it's not possible. If a result is confirmed in many studies by many authors using many datasets and many methodologies, that's how we know we can trust a result. I personally do not put much weight on a single paper's results unless there's something special about it.

The most important thing is that everything about the investigation is open: the methodology (including everything not found in the paper), the programs, the data. It's more like posting code for a large project on Github and then new researchers make PRs to correct bugs or extend the program in useful ways.

Re:What my retraction taught me by einpoklum on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:46PM (#25864007)
I think you're conflating correctness and degrees of validity.

Yes, I expect journals to have to have correct results - not in the sense that the generalizations from their findings are universally valid, but in that the statements of fact and of logical implications are valid.

To be more explicit:

* "Events X, Y, Z occurred" <- expect this kind of sentences to be correct

* "We did X, Y, Z" <- expect this kind of sentences to be correct

* "A and A->B, so B" <- expect this kind of sentences to be correct

* "We therefore conclude that X" <- Don't expect X to necessarily be correct.

Re:What my retraction taught me by kansface on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:48PM (#25865644)
> in that the statements of fact and of logical implications are valid.

See for example https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/05/07/5-httlpr-a-pointed-rev... for a slightly different take.

Re:What my retraction taught me by einpoklum on Thursday January 21, 2021 @06:29PM (#25866123)
I don't see how that disagrees with what I wrote.