News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The pandemic is speeding up the mass exodus of men from c... by s1artibartfast on Thursday January 21, 2021 @02:17PM (#25862852)
Not OP and I dont hold their position, but I wanted to point out that I think your personal attack is undermining productive discussion on this topic.

The OP didn't make any claims about their personal feelings about women, you added that connection, accusing them of threatening and casting them as a brooding predator.

The points could have been raised by a happily married woman with grandchildren.

Re:The pandemic is speeding up the mass exodus of men from c... by jfengel on Thursday January 21, 2021 @02:28PM (#25863022)
I don't believe that they would have been raised by a happily married woman with grandchildren -- or any woman. Oh, you can never say "never", but I think that very, very few women would see themselves in the characterization expressed there.

I cited text that, I believe, women would see as red flags. (I'd let women speak for themselves here, but HN is rather a suasage fest, and it shouldn't fall to the few who are here to do all of the work. If they disagree with me we should certainly discuss that.) Regardless of who the OP actually is in real life, that's the way they presented themselves, and I think it's important to HN readers to see how that is interpreted.

I cannot think of any more productive way to show that. I tried to be as polite and specific as I could while saying what I believe a woman would say, if she felt safe enough to do so. (I reiterate, I wouldn't if I thought it likely that a woman would, in this forum. I'm a secondhand substitute.)

Re:The pandemic is speeding up the mass exodus of men from c... by s1artibartfast on Thursday January 21, 2021 @02:57PM (#25863394)
I appreciate the follow up. Similarly, I just wanted to let you know in good faith how it came off very combative, going after a view of women that wasn't represented in the post (at least to me). I understand different people have different views, and discussions of mate selection often come off as an incel/misogynist dog whistle. That said, there are real conversations about mate selection, gender dynamics, and loneliness to be had. The hard part is how to do it without digressing into a male/female blame game.

Edit: IF there is a problem with how men view women (and vice versa) we need to talk about why that is: the mothers, fathers, and society that raised them to hold those views.

Re:The pandemic is speeding up the mass exodus of men from c... by jfengel on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:13PM (#25863607)
Thank you. I see how it comes off as combative, and I can't think of a non-combative way to say "I think you've got a very wrong world-view". Perhaps the word "misogynist" right up front is more hostile than it needs to be, but I don't believe it's inaccurate.

And you're absolutely correct to note that mothers, as well as fathers, are involved, as are wives, girlfriends, female friends, and sisters. The problem is deeply pervasive, and women are just as imbued in this culture as men are.

It's why I wanted to call out the red flags in the post. The OP later said that he's gay, and is approaching this as an abstraction. The abstraction is part of the problem: the model he's swimming in is flawed. The problems with it are so glaring that there's no way to point them out without seeming hostile.

Re:The pandemic is speeding up the mass exodus of men from c... by s1artibartfast on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:52PM (#25864080)
If you main point was that women (in general) don't use income when considering partners, and it is primarily men (in general) who tie their social relationship value to income, then I think this is fundamental premise for the discussion.

I think there is some truth to both sides. There is a time in the not so distant past where female involvement in the labor pool and earnings was a fraction of what it is now, and men were judged by women and others on their ability to provide for a financially stable family.

Cultural values are evolving, but I personally think this is still on the minds of many, and deeply ingrained in our culture. Female earnings have grown, but the ability to support a family with a single income have diminished. I think that being unemployed or low earning is still an unattractive attribute, but not insurmountable.

Something that the earlier poster failed to cover, that I think could be more significant is the impact of a educational divide on the ability to find common interests and beliefs. The worldview, interests, and exposure to broad ideas that come with education have a profound impact on the ability of individuals to form and maintain relationships.