The reason I like the approach you describe is because it keeps things simpler at the start of a project and consistent across most projects.
I also think it makes sense to have those support containers build on a schedule. For example, you build your build/CI container weekly and that’s the CI container for the week. On demand project builds use that CI container which has all dependencies, etc. baked in.
It would be nice if CI systems would let me explicitly tag builds as (non)reproducible.
And just to be clear, I'm not building (no human) the base image. The base image is also created within it's own build pipeline that has all of the necessary things to track its materialization and lineage. Logs, manifests, etc...
Once the image has been thoroughly tested and verified (both by humans and verification scripts) each time a change is merged, the git repo is tagged, docker image is built and tagged and then pushed to the container repo.
Perhaps you could explain what you mean by the other way? Why would you ever need to recreate the base image? Perhaps if the container repo dropped off the face of the earth and had to be created from scratch?
For instance, we create base images configured with SDKs, libraries, frameworks, configurations, binaries, etc...
Those base images are then built, versioned, tagged and then pushed to our container repos ready to be used by developers, CI/CD, etc...
Images based on these base images never need an apt-get, pip install, etc... If there is a dependency missing, updated needed, etc... we'll create a new base image with it, following the steps above.
I would love some constructive feedback.