News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by mcritz on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @07:46PM (#2586036)
I felt similarly. “Why not write a blog post?” I thought.
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by saraid216 on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @08:27PM (#2586144)
A blog post in 1999 is asking a little much.
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by starwed on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @08:38PM (#2586170)
But then again, Ender's Game included the general idea of blogs as a plot point... (Not sure what else you would classify Peter/Valentine's self-published online essays as.)
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by icarus_drowning on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @08:49PM (#2586184)
Aren't they explicitly described as forum postings?
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by a1k0n on Thursday May 26, 2011 @12:16AM (#2586584)
Yeah, it's described as something more akin to Usenet than anything else from what I remember.
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by starwed on Thursday May 26, 2011 @07:23AM (#2587317)
Yeah, they were using some use-net like technology to post, since the web wasn't really around when the book was written.

I'd argue they carried the same social role as blogs. To me, the key vision is that online, self-published essays could be widely read and influential.

-edit- Actually referencing the book, they do eventually become part of "newsnets", being paid for their work and gaining a wider audience.

It also describes them using temporary anonymous accounts, injecting deliberately inflammatory comments into discussions to provoke a response. >_>

Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by rdl on Friday May 27, 2011 @07:58PM (#2593493)
Yes. And, sadly, USENET still has a lot of ways it was superior to current web-based forums, blogs, etc.
Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by pseudonym on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @11:48PM (#2586524)
I find it hard to resist posting the obvious XKCD reference (http://xkcd.com/635/).

On a more salient point, I always find it interesting to compare the idea of anonymity in the Ender world compared to what we have now. I'd be curious in seeing Card's take on it; despite how prescient the idea of a blog was, I don't think he ever conceived of how massively outweighed the signal could be compared to the amount of noise.

Re:Orson Scott Card's Amazon Review of Ender's Game by Kadin on Thursday May 26, 2011 @02:43AM (#2586861)
IIRC Orson Scott Card had his own area on AOL in the mid 90s, and possibly earlier. Not sure when he moved to the big-boy Internet but the name is the same, "Hatrack River".

It wasn't a 'blog' per se, more of a forum, I think ... I only dropped in once or twice and my recollection was that the discussion was (at the time) more about his religion than about his writing.

But if he'd just wanted to speak to fans he's certainly had an outlet to do so for a long time, and had it at the time the review was written. Presumably he chose to write the response in the form of an Amazon review consciously, and not for want of some other venue.