Re:Ads Implant False Memories
by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @11:11AM
(#2584223)
I'm suspicious of experimental method. Did the "false memory" students really not eat the popcorn? Really? Students? They didn't get their friend to sneak them some, or go in after the test and taste it? Surely they would not have revealed this 'cheat' to the interviewer a week later in any case.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Or maybe they were confused. There's no such thing as "Orville Redenbacher’s Gourmet Fresh Microwave Popcorn", but you can go down to the store and buy some "Orville Redenbacher Gourmet Popping Corn", so do the researchers really expect me to remember the difference?
That is the thread of this that I would pull if I had a spare platoon of researchers to send into this territory. How distinctive a memory is "implantable"? As it is, I guess we will just have to wait until someone else does that work.
Speaking of... is there some good way to get notified when a paper is published which builds on some known body of work? Like can I get an email digest updating me if any of a set of papers are referenced in new papers?
Addendum: Yes... "Track Citation" on JSTOR does this (if one makes an account)... I doubt it does a pretty digest that helps me remember why I wanted to know about the new papers (what question about the original paper I was interested in having future research nail down), but it will have to do for now.
Much more distinctive memories have been "implanted" by mistake, such as child abuse.
Re:Ads Implant False Memories
by charlieflowers on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @08:10PM
(#2586098)
The way I read it, the false memory wasn't that they ate it last week ... it was that they have ever eaten it. And since the fake product name sounds so much like real product names, it sounds like they were just confused over the name. Which undermines the point of the study significantly.
Am I reading something wrong?
I'm also a bit wary of the results as well. Because it's a very trivial event, the recollection isn't important.
Did I eat popcorn last week? Dunno, don't care.
Re:Ads Implant False Memories
by JonnieCache on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @01:33PM
(#2584779)
Most memories in life are trivial though, so any findings are still useful.