News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by jl2718 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @09:55AM (#25833947)
Let’s ask the naive question here. Why would an American company go to Russia to exercise their American right to free speech?
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by recursive on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:04AM (#25834773)
Because no American company wants to touch it with a 10 foot pole.

People get confused about the difference between free expression, and compelling companies to support that expression.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by trident5000 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:12AM (#25834868)
Your statement is true. Its also true that the tech market is too consolidated to be considered a free market.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by throwaway189262 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:26AM (#25835057)
True. But there's nothing stopping Parler from running their own servers either. There's many controversial physical businesses in the US that would have trouble renting. But nothing stops them from buying their own land.

That's the issue with Parler hosting. With hosting, you're digitally renting.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by BitwiseFool on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:32AM (#25835144)
It's more complicated than that because other companies that aren't related to hosting decided to refuse service to Parler. Mastercard, Twilio, various Law Firms, and others. The truth is that running any service of scale requires dozens of other companies from other industries.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by throwaway189262 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @01:03AM (#25843036)
True. And most companies would decide it wasn't economical to run such a controversial site at scale.

But this is being painted as "monopolies against free speech", and it's not. There's hundreds, maybe thousands of hosting companies. At least dozens of ways to take payments. Thousands of law firms.

I think everyone is in agreement that big tech has too much influence. But big tech isn't what's keeping Parler off the web. It's not "leftists" either. It's legal liability for things like the capital riots.

Legal liability, aka the threat of government is what's keeping Parker offline. Not big tech. All the US companies are just falling in line, protecting themselves from lawsuits and expensive court cases

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by trident5000 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:37AM (#25835196)
The biggest issue is really the app stores. If hosting keeps consolidating the way it is, it will be on par in future years. And the reason Parler didn't build its own servers is because its massively expensive to do so. So expensive that its a non-starter rather than an inconvenience. Giving preferential treatment to some startups but not others to cut the corner on hosting by dominant players which determines winners and losers is still not a free market.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by IOT_Apprentice on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:59AM (#25835493)
Anyone with enough money can enter the market. Parler is funded by a billionaire. She just has to spend more of her money to compete or acquire what she needs.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by BitwiseFool on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:14AM (#25834879)
I'm starting to think the "Free Market" doesn't exist and it's really just a platonic ideal.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by trident5000 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:15AM (#25834897)
Free markets exist when the DOJ does its job.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by nextaccountic on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:06PM (#25835622)
Do you mean that the very existence of free markets depends on strict governmental regulation?

Without state intervention, free market don't remain free on its own?

So, what is free about free markets?

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by joshuamorton on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:30PM (#25835966)
This is how Adam Smith described free markets, potentially influenced by regulation to ensure monopolies and rent seeking didn't exist.

In that framing, the market is free from economic privilege, and individual actors are free to compete on equal footing.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by nextaccountic on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:47PM (#25836233)
Thanks, this makes sense.

What confuses me is the overloading of "free market" to mean something opposed to government intervention.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by trident5000 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:54PM (#25836358)
Government set the rules in free markets. A free market is a competitive market with even rules for all participants.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by joshuamorton on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @02:52PM (#25837979)
Yes, lots of anti-regulation people have taken a specific brand of free-market capitalism (arguably even an extremist brand of laissez-faire free-market capitalism) and tried to make that the only "real" market economy.

Free market socialism isn't a contradiction, despite what many would have you believe (think: worker owned co-operatives and nonprofits that compete in the broader market).

Similarly, market economies need not be wholly unregulated to be good. And indeed, I think you'd be hard pressed to find mainstream economists who claim that worker safety regulations are bad (like, they might be able to point to particular regulations that are dumb, but there are many that are not).

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by jl2718 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @02:11PM (#25837423)
Seems like a general concept. The concept of government is actually a forceful limitation on the powers that would be exercised in a state of anarchy. Otherwise theres no distinction between ‘government’ run by a dictator, and anarchy with a singularly powerful individual. Of course the distinction can be rationalized away further in terms of collective power until the only thing left is a theocracy. But practically, .... actually I don’t know anymore.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by trident5000 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:21PM (#25835837)
The concept that the govt is a director of the free markets and ensure they remain competitive is older than years you have on this earth.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by jl2718 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:57PM (#25837186)
Why not? What are all the American companies afraid of?
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by jfengel on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @04:51PM (#25839386)
Being complicit in insurrection. Insurrection itself, for that matter, but the part that hits close to home is that they might be blamed for being involved.

Everybody got real nervous when people invaded the US Congress in order to stop it from certifying an election. Regardless of what you call that event, it was very illegal, and nobody wants to be anywhere near it should it happen again.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by jl2718 on Friday January 22, 2021 @11:58PM (#25879794)
This seems like a uniquely internet concern. Nobody seems to hold accountable the supply chains of controversial offline products.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by IOT_Apprentice on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:58AM (#25835472)
Because they both support sedition against the USA. Anything that furthers turmoil in the US is to Russia's advantage. The Government did not shut down Parler, the free market did. Parler is free to set up their own infrastructure.

Perhaps Rebekah Mercer, the big money behind them, can buy a data center to house their servers, she has the money to do so. Or she can purchase a cloud/ISP company to house her other properties like Brietbart.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by grawprog on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:54PM (#25836362)
>The Government did not shut down Parler, the free market did

Amazon's been receiving cia, military and other US government contracts for years now.

https://theatlantic.com/article/374632/

https://www.technologyreview.com/2019/10/08/75349/meet-ameri...

https://aws.amazon.com/contract-center/#federal

Amazon took a website off their services critical of the government and incoming administration.

If amazon did this to a company critical of one of their private contract companies, this would be anti-trust behaviour.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by Dystopian on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @02:49PM (#25837939)
> If amazon did this to a company critical of one of their private contract companies, this would be anti-trust behaviour.

No it wouldn't be. That is not how anti-trust works. Amazon doesn't need to rent servers to Walmart. Walmart doesn't need to rent storage space or placement to Amazon. There's nothing in anti-trust which compells companies to have to provide services to one another.

If people want to talk about these issues they need to frame it in terms of strengthening anti-discrimination laws for speech. If that's something we want to talk about it's valid - it's just not the route most people getting angry about this want to take since it would run against many other opinions they've made previously (Masterpiece Cakeshop, et al.)

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by grawprog on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @04:36PM (#25839207)
I can't understand why these platforms are being treated just like any other private company to be honest.

These companies openly take billions of dollars in government subsidies and tax breaks, most of them have one or more contracts with the US government, several of them received funding from the government during their early days, without which, there's a chance they may not be the giants they are today.

How much money should tax payers continue funding these massive corporations before they should finally get a say in their actions?

These companies willingly accept these billions of dollars, wllingly chose to put themselves in the position of being the 'new town square', then they hide behind the 'nope private company' argument.

All I know is, when I was working off government subsidies and grants years ago, i was publically accountable for anything we did and we had far less public impact than any of these companies.

People can argue laws and semantics all they want, but what will it actually take for people to actually recognize the power these companies have over nearly every aspect of modern life and stop just treating them as

'Any other private company'.

That's an excuse and as far as i'm concerned a completely bullshit one. It's very obvious that's not the case and how anyone can deny this is mind boggling to me.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by acct776 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:01PM (#25835530)
> The Government did not shut down Parler, the free market did.

The new inception of the Moral Majority did.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by IOT_Apprentice on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:19PM (#25835807)
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by IOT_Apprentice on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:07PM (#25835627)
Again, the Government did not. Rebekah Mercer and the Koch family et al are free to acquire a datacenter or cloud hosting company and build out a payments infrastructure as well. Nothing is stopping them from doing so.

I'm sure Rupert Murdoch would also be glad to contribute as well. Let capitalism thrive! AWS, Stripe, Paypal, GoFundMe have zero OBLIGATION to provide services to them.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by tharne on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:27PM (#25835928)
An oligopoly is not an example of the "Free Market". It's the opposite.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by gurleen_s on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @10:20AM (#25834218)
No government body was restricting their free speech. It was only the free market refusing to do business with them.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by trident5000 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:17AM (#25834931)
"free market" aka 2 coordinating app stores with complete dominance. Server hosting is a step down in oligopoly behavior but its consolidating fast.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by FireBeyond on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:32PM (#25835992)
Android devices allow side loading, and as noted, you don't need an app to use Parler.

Server hosting is still entirely a commodity.

"Cloud Providers" are also a (smaller) commodity. Vendor tie-in (to things like AWS) is a problem for a number of businesses entirely less controversial than Parler.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by Mediterraneo10 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:50PM (#25836299)
> Android devices allow side loading

Possibly not for long, though. There has been speculation that Google will push to have its "Advanced Protection" model extended to mass-market phones. This would make it impossible to side-load apps, except for that tiny minority of nerds like us who know how to enable ADB and push the app to the device over the command line.

Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by trident5000 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:44PM (#25836198)
And I get get into the cake store by going through the dark alley and into the back entrance even though the front door sign says closed. Everyone knows the reach is drastically limited, which is the entire point.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by FireBeyond on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:58PM (#25836411)
I'm sorry, remind me again what inherent right you have to a third party paying to ensure you have bright lights and big signs on your front door?
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by IOT_Apprentice on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:01PM (#25835531)
Parler does not need a app, they can be a fully functioning site for conservative hate speech by using the latest in web technology. They don't need a app.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by birdyrooster on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:05AM (#25834780)
Rights are only as good as what your peers are willing to accept. I am sure everyone in the US would agree you have the right to speak your ideas aloud, practice whatever religion you want, and vote for your favorite candidate. Beyond that, which is the first amendment, you are venturing into a gray zone where precedence and common law rule. There is no amendment that says your vendors must continue doing business with you so that you can have the maximum reach for your ideas.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by BitwiseFool on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:11AM (#25834847)
The consensus seems to be that the right to free speech is only guaranteed by the government and the ideal of free speech doesn't need to be upheld by a corporation. The US government doesn't provide DDoS protection or hosting services so the only other alternative is to find a company outside of the US willing to host you.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by rasz on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:57PM (#25836385)
Because it was founded by a techbro dude who just happened to fall in love with random Russian girl visiting Vegas cough Butina cough, and proceeded to move to Russia where they got married?
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by mansion7 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @07:54PM (#25841199)
The same reason Snowden had to go there.
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by kordlessagain on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @12:42PM (#25836158)
Because the CEO is married to a Russian?
Re:Parler partially reappears with support from Russian tech... by netsharc on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @10:20AM (#25834212)
To play devil's advocate, imagine a chat app for Iranians that faces an attack from their government, and asks an EU-based company to host them...

Sadly in the alternate reality, people believe tomorrow the "Deep State" will install a regime to take over the country of the "true patriots"...