Re:Mozilla rejects Google's WebP image format
by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday May 25, 2011 @08:22AM
(#2583702)
You mention that it has better compression, which Microsoft certainly claims for it, but can you find any comparison that shows XR as better than standard JPEG when measured with SSIM rather than PSNR? Or subjective human tests[1]? There's quite a few showing it losing to JPEG. Surely they can't all have messed up their testing methodology, though creating and standardising a purpose built photo codec in 2009 that's worse in quality at many common rates than JPEG seems somewhat unbelievable too.
1: "the visual performance of HDPhoto showed notable deficits, both in subjective and objective tests."
from Visual Quality Improvement Techniques of HDPhoto/JPEG-XR by T Richter
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?arnumber=04712398
Is it really just because it was made by Microsoft?