Re:Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the e...
by franga2000 on Monday January 18, 2021 @05:23AM
(#25820258)
That is my whole point though: the WebExtensions API is a standard, so it's not like you can't test your extension without owning a Mac. If your extension works on both Firefox and Chrome, it really should work on Safari too. If it doesn't, that's Apple's fault for violating the standard, not yours for not testing on their broken platform. If you want to specifically test it you can, but if you don't see a reason to, you should be able to just port it over and let people use it and beta test it for you.
Re:Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the e...
by coldtea on Monday January 18, 2021 @06:18AM
(#25820578)
>If your extension works on both Firefox and Chrome, it really should work on Safari too. If it doesn't, that's Apple's fault for violating the standard, not yours for not testing on their broken platform.
Chrome is notorious for building this that are not standards and forcing them into standards bodies later. That's part of "but it works on Chrome" web issue.
So not working on Safari doensn't necessarily mean it's the fault of Safari for "violating the standard". Could very well be for upholding the standards over Chrome ad-hoc/de-facto "standard" additions...
Re:Safari 14 added WebExtensions support, so where are the e...
by franga2000 on Monday January 18, 2021 @08:39AM
(#25821635)
Which is why I mentioned both Chrome and Firefox, as while both implement some non-standard features, those tend to differ, so the intersection of their feature sets is pretty much the standard itself.
I was actually referring to "your extensions following the standard", but since you can't exactly test against the standard directly, I used testing against both browsers as a good approximation.
Well, we don't have standards for native apps, only partial standards for different APIs and protocols, so there's that.
And the change Apple made, to allow for Chrome-like extensions, is already more "standard" than before (where it was Safari-only extension APIs). It just requires one more step.