Getting a large swath of people vaccinated is more valuable than perfectly getting prioritization right. Prior to this change, NY was attempting to perfect prioritization, and was discarding many doses as they expired.
See https://www.jstor.org/stable/4531385?seq=1
In my opinion, the US’s top level goals were wrong (over focus on equity versus utility) and the US bureaucracy is neither flexible nor creative as evidenced by its refusal to buck top level orders and it’s continuing slowness. These are signs of a decaying system.
Yes, and it’s because the priorities rank as follows for each individual:
1) personal liability
2) organizational liability
3) utility
Where liability includes both legal and public relations consequences. It’s exhausting to constantly think about open ended and unintended consequences that you might be held accountable for, with no recourse.
Michigan (my state) is doing about 35,000 doses on weekdays at this point, which is frustratingly slow. But if they had spun up twice as fast, we wouldn't be doing 70,000 doses a day, we'd be out of vaccine.
The most recent shipments have been ~120,000 vaccines/week for 2 weeks and then none for a third week. So if the tempo of Federal allotments is 120,000 a week, the 35,000 a day is not a bottleneck. They should of course be building capacity anyway, with the idea that deliveries will increase (and making a plan for what to do if/when the adenovirus vaccines are approved in the US; fortunately it looks like that can be "send it everywhere").
Anyway, wasting vaccines is obviously stupid, I'm not trying to argue about that.
Exactly. Any person getting a dose is better than vaccine expiring
This is "once this vaccine is pulled out of the super-cold freezer, it starts breaking down, and you have X hours before it's worthless at best."
Worse than "worthless" is the idea that people might get a useless expired vaccine anyway, think they're protected, and then be a vector for future transmission.
What really helped is a very centralized healthcare system with a very long history of managing public emergencies.
This is because Israel was founded as a socialist welfare state, and the impressive healthcare system is one of the leftovers.
A lot is really about overall volume. Even a million vaccinations a day means you're looking at well into the summer until you even approach 50% vaccinated.
I think we’ll see R’ start to plunge during summer due to weather and never climb back up from increase in immunity. But “back to normal”. January earliest.
There are also gradations of normal although once you fully open up restaurants, have indoor concerts, packed auditoriums, etc. most things you could do to reduce spread are pretty much theater at that point (other than possibly requiring vaccinations to fly, enter venues, workplaces).
If somebody is elderly, the chances of them getting an appointment is extremely low without the help (and extreme vigilance) of their tech savvy children/nieces/nephews.
Some states have also opened up their registrations to people 16+ with serious chronic health conditions that put them at high risk of severe COVID-19. In a handful of these states, many of these people have received a vaccine. But, it is first come first serve, which is an absolute disaster along with being inequitable.
That only applies if your application is programmed for it. Good luck scaling even if you had aws if your server had database locks everywhere, for instance.
That there are multiple candidate vaccines targeting the spike protein without using the virus directly is strong evidence that the science was ready (using mRNA, viral vector and other technologies).
To me it is a cop-out to blame the feds. There is nothing to stop any state in our union from addressing this pandemic as they see fit. The states making up the Euro aren't blaming Brussels for their problems.
The converse would be to have one world government make decisions for everybody, right? That would work if we all agreed on everything, but we don't. So it is good to have different states try different solutions, and copy what works. Better then having a bad federal solution imposed on everyone.
Except for zero funding...
My state is definitely to blame too, our new governor is an absolute disaster. But, we also have no serious funding left to handle the pandemic. Our last governor started a rainy day fund years ago and exhausted that last year, along with part of our wildfire fund. There is nothing left for us without federal assistance.
There is absolutely a middle ground between putting everything on the state and having one government rule the entire world. The federal government is the best equipped entity in the United States for handling the pandemic. It has the funding, personnel, and logistics management to efficiently distribute vaccines.
The fact that some states are not doing a good job doesn't incline me to want to gamble on the federal government doing better. They don't have a good track record in emergencies.
You might end up punishing the states who are doing ok, and possibly causing a lot of problems forcing everyone into one solution.
At some point politicians need to be held accountable. Passing the buck for everything is not a great answer.
Its only the state's responsibility now because the federal government fumbled hard initially and had to pass blame because it was an election year. When is the last time states had to handle disaster relief on this scale with little to no assistance from the Federal government? A strong central force is crucial to handling crises like this, ours just blew it.
You can have input from local officials on setting up locations and timelines for clinics, but the 12 people making 20$/hr working in my local health department shouldnt have to deal with some of the most complex logistics the country has ever seen.
This is absolutely the best time to mobilize the massive military logistics chain in order to distribute and use vaccines as fast as possible.
If states are truly doing a great job (not many are), they can always decline assistance, but it isnt even being offered in the first place at this point.
> At some point politicians need to be held accountable. Passing the buck for everything is not a great answer.
Are you not just passing the blame onto local politicians and off of the federal level ones that hold most of the power?
I think that it is wishful thinking to believe the military could be re-purposed to make a significant difference. Their job is to blow things up and kill people. It seems the field hospitals deployed were a drop in the bucket, and I assume that all doctors and nurses are already busy. What else would you expect from them, or the rest of the federal government? I'd be afraid of a single bad solution being forced on everyone. The feds have a pretty bad record of moving fast.
Perhaps this is just a difficult situation and is not going to go as smooth as you'd wish? There's no magic bullet here. It's a pandemic. Covid has killed as many people per-capita as the low end of the estimated 1-4 million deaths from the 1968 Hong Kong flu. These things happen.
Also there is no widespread disagreement on what the response should be. i.e. Would our national response follow the NY model or the Florida model?
Yes, I would blame states for local problems. If your state setup a system leaving twelve local $20/hr employees in a bad situation I would say that is your state's fault. What makes you think the feds could do a more effective job?
Not all states are doing a bad job.
I do not know if there is correlation though, based on looking at Bloomberg vaccine tracker. However, it appears so.
You have people over 75 years old who were waiting and registering on whatever reservation system was cobbled together on short notice, and then because the public health authorities now risked throwing out doses for want of people to inject them into, they just opened the floodgates to everyone over 65.
So what happens to the people over 75 who were waiting, and now are swamped by the crowds? If they keep on opening up bulk tranches of the population (instead of in small slices) before people of priority are reached, when will the most vulnerable ever get their turn?
This is a known problem. Multiple queues of priority and people on call to be given turns the next day if it looks like there's capacity.
Instead you have people wondering if they should walk in, visit a county next door, or wait around in case some mistake is made and there are actually extra doses at the end of a day. Or try to scheme/figure out the system however they can, out of desperation.
If it can't be done right, let everyone know that it's up to their willingness to wait wherever they can, according to some basic ground rules, and don't make a meaningless (or worse, deceptive) reservations system that gets bypassed at the last minute.
What a shameful clusterfuck.