News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by taeric on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:10PM (#25812432)
Is this even that controversial of a take?
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by techwizrd on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:16PM (#25812523)
Unfortunately, it is. Nationalism has surged in popularity across the globe, and I think they would disagree with this take. I do not think nationalism would be as popular as it is if the GP's comment was uncontroversial.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by igorkraw on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:19PM (#25812559)
If you follow it to it's conclusion to abolish nation states and create a world level confederacy ala EU or a politically binding UN, yes very much so. Usually people try to give some defense of patriotism or "acceptable" nationalism, but in my opinion the truth is that until we have the whole planet in a multilayer jurisdiction where local problems are solved locally but there's a clear path towards escalation into global jurisdiction, nationalism will continue to fuck us.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by treis on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:42PM (#25812830)
I don't think that's necessarily the conclusion. One of the major changes after WWII is that now mostly all the Germans lived in Germany, Poles in Poland, Czechs in Czechloslovakia, French in France, etc. That seems to have led to a stable solution. Conversely, the places where ethnicity and/or religion are mixed are constant sources of strife. This conclusion leads to a lot of dark places so it is rightfully rejected on those grounds, but it does seem to work.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by igorkraw on Friday January 22, 2021 @02:16PM (#25875097)
I mean, that observation that you need cultural homogeneity (the most charitable version) is simply wrong. Switzerland has been multi cultural for hundreds of years and continues to be so, the US hasn't seen a civil war in a similarly long time, thinking of china or india as culturally homogenous is silly and on a larger scale, the roman, byzantine and ottoman empires were stable internally over stretches from decades to centuries.

The root cause of strife isn't hetereogenity, it's lack of institutions and mechanisms to resolve strife without violence.

Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by taeric on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:46PM (#25812878)
Why is that the conclusion? Seems an absurd reduction. Would also lead to abolishing family, which would have no real benefits.

I agree with it as a reaction to the idea that strong fences make good neighbors. Good neighbors aren't a static thing. But as an end goal reduction? Seems lacking. A strong set of nations seems to be more benefitted from all nations in the set being strong. Not in any domination.

Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by oa335 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:28PM (#25812675)
This is an idea that I have been kicking around in my head for several years and I’m interested in learning more about it. Do you have any recommendations on writers that expound on what the world would look like without nation states?
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by robin21 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @05:30PM (#25815865)
Super interesting thought. Seems like it would make a good book. Something like Sapiens, looking through history but with a focus on why nation states arose and fell, and then extrapolating. The EU is a great modern case study. The topic of [Federation](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federation) is a good starting point to, because to get to world like that would involve several steps of federation, or some all-encompassing treaties.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by haunter on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:43PM (#25812837)
The Project for Perpetual Peace, written in the 18th century but still timeless

https://www.amazon.com/Abridged-Version-Project-Perpetual-Pe...

Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by disposekinetics on Sunday January 17, 2021 @04:21PM (#25815080)
Your solution to nationalism is a government you cannot flee from. At least with two states if one mistreats you it is possible to flee.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by dash2 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:23PM (#25812617)
It is not controversial at all, among a wide swathe of the public. But I think it's wrong.

Nationalism is in-group altruism, focused on the members of a particular political unit. It has the disadvantage of excluding outsiders. We all know that this can lead to war and to hatred of outsiders. Noone can say that nationalism has no dark side.

However, the advantage of nationalism is that it is realistic. It has a focused goal: this state should be run for the benefit of the people living in it. The goal is achievable, as can be seen by the existence of modern nation-states with features like democracy, written constitutions, law courts and social welfare.

An alternative to nationalism is internationalism. That sounds better: nobody is excluded! But internationalism, like the Pope, has no battalions. It has few existing, global institutions that can be used to get things done. Some people think we should push for more such institutions, maybe by empowering the UN. Others reasonably reply that a world government might easily become a world tyranny. Others used to believe that international socialism, and the workers of the world, might provide the "battalions". The twentieth century showed that to be a dangerous dead end.

In the absence of those institutions, internationalism tends to devolve into hot air. If you disagree, and think of yourself as an internationalist, ask yourself how much of your money you have spent helping the world as a whole. If it's less than 1%, I accuse you - no offence - of talking hot air. By contrast, I pay large amounts of taxes to my nation's government. I have to (which is a good thing), but even voluntarily, I do things like voting, which helps keep democracy going.

In short, nationalism is the only system of widespread altruism that actually works.

Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by Fanch22 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:42PM (#25812829)
> It has the disadvantage of excluding outsiders

And pacifists (see leon Blum in 1914).

And people who generally don't agree or arn't part of the national imagination, but nevertheless are part of the nation (southern USSR around WW2?).

In general the nationalism of the general population is easy to exploit for people who don't care and have the power to do so.

Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by plumble on Sunday January 17, 2021 @05:37PM (#25815936)
Your problem is that modern "nationalist" movements do not have the goal of "this state should be run for the benefit of the people living in it".

It's "this state should be run for the benefit of <ethnic group>, and anyone else should be purged". It's about ethnic groups, not citizenship.

Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by oa335 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:32PM (#25812722)
“Nationalism is the only system of widespread altruism that works” sounds a lot like “the horse and buggy is the only system of long distance transportation that actually works”.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by dash2 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @03:21PM (#25814547)
Sure, if you invent the automobile, tell me about it. I've said why I think the alternatives are inferior.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by taeric on Sunday January 17, 2021 @04:27PM (#25815141)
This ignores some forms of religion. A fairly old cross national system. Complete with is own set of problems.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by dash2 on Monday January 18, 2021 @05:32AM (#25820313)
Yup, that's an excellent point. Religion invokes various kinds of altruism - often though not always limited to the in-group - and it clearly "works" in some sense and has survived for millennia. I guess it's hard to recommend religion to someone on that basis though, because that is not the basis that religion recommends itself on. You can't become a Christian because you think (like Rodney Stark) that Christians are very helpful to each other. You can only be a Christian by accepting Christ as your personal saviour.
Re:Mahatma Gandhi's killer venerated as Hindu nationalism re... by taeric on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @11:18AM (#25834955)
"Accepting" the belief of a religion is far less friction than moving to a place. Not even comparable to having been born there. :D