And remember that a power company can cut off power to people if they are intentionally attempting to disrupt the power system, or simply not paying.
Yes, this is what's under discussion. One side of the debate thinks that the big social media products are critical enough to societal (and especially political) discourse that access should be guaranteed through regulation. It's a rather radical claim, and not one I'm sure I agree with, but it's not self-inconsistent.
> And remember that a power company can cut off power to people if they are intentionally attempting to disrupt the power system, or simply not paying.
Yes, and FB/Twitter can ban people for plenty of reasons that no one considers particularly controversial or critical. As with the power companies, the claim is that doing so for expressing legal-but-unpopular political speech is not conducive to the health of civic discourse and thus democracy.
> Power companies (1) get paid by their users
I don't see what this has to do with anything.
If you don't like it, you might be politically aligned with a progressive value: Regulate monopolies not speech.
Note that I'm speaking in the voice of those making this claim, not personally espousing the claim. My inclination is away from kneejerk regulation, and I don't think distribution on the Internet fits neatly into the existing categories we use to reason about market power. I'm just shocked at the degree to which so many HNers are gleefully misrepresenting the issue, presumably so they don't have to engage in any critical thinking.
By and large people don't pay to use social media, so while a person uses power even if the utility company doesn't like it, they are still compensated.
If someone is using social media for reasons/things they don't like, they're now going to take the publicity hit for hosting it, while also paying to host it against their will.
I'd have more sympathy for the argument if the people forcing the hosting of content against the SMCs will had some system for compensating the SMC as well.
Again, I'm not taking a position here, but the legions of strawmen being propped up to misrepresent one side of the discussion isn't helping anyone (or one could say, "is degrading the service for other users").
What's under discussion is whether "the new public square" of Twitter/Facebook/et al constitute the same manner of oligopolistically-provided service that everyone has a right to.