Capital punishment is not an issue of freedom, it's an issue of justice - another core American value.
I don’t think capital punishment is the only way to have justice, but I see it as a different concern than freedom.
I think the freedom to live is the most fundamental freedom of all – every other freedom is dependent on the freedom to live, because to enjoy any other freedom you first have to be alive.
If capital punishment is justice, why isn't corporal punishment equally so? If justice can be served by killing a person, why can it not also be served by flogging them or cutting off their hand? Do Iran and Saudi Arabia, in that regard, therefore have more justice than America?
On the other hand, in the US the government (federally and in 28 states) has the right to kill you if it can get 12 jurors to say you've done something so bad you deserve to die. So, it seems Australians may not have the same right to own guns, but they have a greater right to life. Why count one right and ignore the other?