Any site that doesn't allow opting out of micro targeting should be banned by government.
But to say nothing would be lost from banning it because its always used without regard for health and dignity is way to far.
Brands like Zappos Adaptive which sells adult shoes that don't need to be tied to people with Autism. Its very hard to do this kind of sales without targeting people affected by disability. The same goes for companies innovating in Wheelchairs, diabetes care, etc..
Because I actually find these recommendations valuable.
In general what I am against is advertisements where
- the advertiser can choose targets based on too fine grained categories (micro categories)
- people get classified with too fine grained categories
(Both points are mostly the same.)
So "people who bought this book also bought books X,Y,Z" is IMHO fine, even if it can sometime lead to bad situations as it can be abused much less. (EDIT: But that partially because it shows real products, "people who have seen XY news also see Z news" would be a different thing.)
Manipulation implies that you're lying to people to get them to buy things, but is it easy to make that argument for FB? What would be the leading argument here?
And why should we think that automated processes tend towards manipulation (lying) as a strategy in the marketplace?
No it means you are trying to change their behavior, usually in an unscrupulous way.
These ads aren't lying. But they are certainly pushing a narrative. Which at best, is normalizing the violent actions taken. And at worst, is recruiting people for that cause.
You don't need to lie to do that.
Exactly this is why I think micro targeting should simply be banned by governments.
I mean:
- It's fundamental meant to manipulate people.
- It's easy to abuse and not really possible to control.
- Discriminatory micro advertisement, weather on a gender, race, religion or similar basis are pretty common for affected people, but at the same time hard to detect for Facebook or any control organization.
- Category combinations which indirectly target addicts are repeatedly used to target them with ad's promoting what this people are addicted to, e.g. gambling.
- *The value it provides for the consumer is questionable.*
- *The value it provides for a ethnically acceptable free marked are questionable.*
- As far as I can tell the only ones noticeable profiting (and as such majorly losing out from a ban) from it are such which act without any regard for the health and dignity/well being of the consumer and society in total (well and big ad platforms).