If John criticizes Heinz in the usual english "irrelevant positive, important negative, irrelevant positive" structure, Heinz's takeaway will be "mostly positive with minor problems". All the while John meant the negative to be a major problem and just wanted to cushion the blow. If Heinz wants to convey criticism, he will give you just the negative, nothing else. Whatever isn't mentioned is OK. John will understand this as devastating criticism, because absolutely nothing positive was mentioned. But actually Heinz liked everything and just has this minor nit to pick... If Heinz likes everything he'll say "it's fine". John might be wondering why he didn't mention anything Heinz liked explicitly and if this is Heinz being passive aggressive.
There is a lot more to it, and of course there are nuances to it, e.g. Heinz might come from various German regions that differ in their usual behaviour and may even seem overly rude or overly friendly to other Germans.