Re:Ask HN: Do we need a Google Customers Union? Could it work?
by airza on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:24AM
(#25764141)
The magical thinking comes from trying to organize a significant portion of Google's customer base (all android phone users, all google search users, etc) spontaneously into a body that can really damage their value proposition financially.
In a labor union _all_ of the value is generated by a bunch of people who are geographically close together and able to organize more easily :)
Re:Ask HN: Do we need a Google Customers Union? Could it work?
by paultopia on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:31AM
(#25764260)
Oh sure, that would be extremely difficult for lots of reasons. But I took OP to be asking in good faith if those difficulties could be surpassed, not assuming they could be.
Re:Ask HN: Do we need a Google Customers Union? Could it work?
by xhkkffbf on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:10AM
(#25763919)
Absolutely. And remember we're not customers, we're the product. So you might call us workers too.
Re:Ask HN: Do we need a Google Customers Union? Could it work?
by geofft on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:48AM
(#25764553)
We're the "product" of services like advertising, but I've seen very few individuals express opinions on Google's advertising product (beyond "stop," or at best "stop tracking me"). Our opinions tend to be on services like Gmail and Drive and Reader and Hangouts. In that case, we're closer to a customer - or more accurately, we're a positive externality. Google does offer paid support for most of these services, including an account rep that you can actually talk to in person. But you have to be paying for them. Individuals who use Gmail for free are effectively just publicity for Google so they can convince large employers to pay them for Gmail.
Re:Ask HN: Do we need a Google Customers Union? Could it work?
by wutbrodo on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:09PM
(#25769294)
> Individuals who use Gmail for free are effectively just publicity for Google so they can convince large employers to pay them for Gmail.
I don't think this is accurate. Having users logged in while using Google Search is worth far, far more to Google than the GSuite sales bump from having free Gmail users.
People organize to engage in collective action outside of governments all the time. In addition to labor unions, consider civil society nonprofits. It's not bizarre or (as another comment suggested) some kind of tech-bro magical thinking to say "hey, the government isn't regulating this group of people, let's organize to get some collective power going."