News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by mjfl on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @01:33AM (#25758918)
I would argue there hasn't been enough cooling. My mother has been having a vicious political argument with my aunts for the better part of a year. Created familial rifts that probably wouldn't have happened without social media.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by divbzero on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @01:43AM (#25758986)
Sadly, I suspect this is not an isolated phenomenon. I’ve increasingly encountered anecdotes of political division souring personal relationships. I wonder if there are systematic surveys or studies of whether this perceived trend is real.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by Dig1t on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @03:32AM (#25759596)
An interesting corollary of this, I think, is that it creates bubbles of people who all think the same and agree with each other. Since it causes many people to cut people with whom they disagree with out of their life.

These people see the people outside their bubble (their neighbors, friends and family) as “other”. It’s so divisive, it’s causing everyone to hate each other as nobody sees common cause with their own countrymen. It’s very sad, I hope we figure it out.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by concordDance on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @04:38AM (#25759997)
They also end up with a very different view on reality due to being exposed to different facts and the same facts with different framing. Filter bubbles be strong.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @04:56AM (#25760103)
In the current climate, there is clearly one portion of the population rejecting reality, even though there’s plenty of available information.

It has nothing to do with bubbles, it’s people actively deciding to delude themselves.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by Veen on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @05:19AM (#25760244)
> there is clearly one portion of the population rejecting reality, even though there’s plenty of available information

That's exactly what the world looks like to a person living in a filter bubble.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @05:33AM (#25760329)
I know. The useful distinction for a filter bubble would be for when a person is exposed only to a small set of ideas, such as “big government, subsidized everything” is the best way, or “small government, privatized everything” is the best way”. Or “so and so method of education is the best way”, things that don’t have relatively definitive answers, based on reasonable logic and standards of evidence.

Using filter bubbles to talk about people that think the earth is 6,000 years old, it’s flat, the US government is run by a cabal pedophiles, vaccines are harmful, the US election results are false, etc is not a fruitful endeavor.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:16AM (#25761081)
If you only encounter "other" ideas in a context where they are derided, mocked and otherwise not taken seriously that's still a pretty damn airtight filter bubble.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:09AM (#25761493)
The information to which I am referring is easily accessible in encyclopedias, university physics departments, CDC/FDA website, wikipedia, state government websites, etc.

The people deluding themselves are choosing to discredit those sources in favor of their favorite celebrity or social group. Or they're pretending for other nefarious reasons. Either way, referring to this as a filter bubble is inaccurate in my opinion.

These people were educated in the US, know English, know how to use the internet, grew up in a diverse country, some are accomplished business people, years long members of the military with lots of international travel. Few people around the world have as much opportunity to be out of their "filter bubble".

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by concordDance on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:18AM (#25761587)
The importance of genes for determining intelligence in humans is also available in Nature, etc. But a large proportion of the population still delusionally believe everyone is the same. Mostly due to filter bubbles.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:41AM (#25761828)
I don't know anyone, prominent or not, that thinks everyone is the SAME. It's trivial for anyone to see identical twins aren't even the same, so unless there is evidence that a "large proportion" of people think this, I assume it's a made up scenario.

I'm also familiar with quite a few cultures around the world, and they all seem to have concepts of being born "gifted" or some version of being naturally talented.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by watwut on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:38AM (#25761251)
There should be however space for saying that a group of people or ideology is simply wrong on some points. We should not be force to pretend that all ideologies, values systems and theories are equal or right. Or honest.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by Dig1t on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:58AM (#25764735)
Agreed you shouldn’t have to agree with anyone you don’t actually agree with, but also tolerance (for _all_ people) is important. We should make an honest attempt to understand WHY these people feel the way they do, and try to address the underlying concerns and fears that motivate them. And if it’s not possible to do that, at least talking about them like they’re not all patently evil would be helpful in building better relationships with our neighbors.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by concordDance on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:14AM (#25761548)
Just one portion?

Many portions I expect. And which portion depends on which bits of reality you look at it. If you think the current canon set of facts of the dominant ideology is 100% correct now when it wasn't any time in the past 2000 years, well... it's just not very likely.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by lotsofpulp on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @08:37AM (#25761802)
Just because we don't have perfect knowledge at any one point in time doesn't mean every single idea throughout history is valid. Overtime, discoveries are made, models are refined, textbooks are updated, and as the evidence presents itself, you keep marching forward with the best available information you have.
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by tomp on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @11:38AM (#25764367)
You mean the side that claims US elections are 100% safe?

I think that Trump definitively lost, but from the point of view of a European (from a former socialist country no less!) the idea that you can have "secure" voting without seeing a person and checking their ID card is ... laughable to say the least.

Yet claiming that as fact is in line with the current propaganda, so ...

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by theshrike79 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @04:31AM (#25759942)
Let me guess, two-party system? It tends to polarise people into an us-vs them mentality.

In actual democracies with a half-dozen actual viable options or more, we don't tend to get that heated with politics in general.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by cafard on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:38AM (#25760821)
Really? I have a hard time coming up with important examples. Germany 1870-1932 had many parties with substantial representation, but how civil was it, particularly after 1918? Mark Twain's essay "Stirring Times in Austria" gives a picture of a multi-party parliament in a nervous breakdown. George Dangerfield's The Strange Death of Liberal England shows the UK ca. 1910 with two large parties, Liberal and Conservative, and two unignorable smaller ones, Labor and the Irish caucus; it was not pretty.

At this point, does any major European country have more than two viable parties or coalitions? Will the German Greens ever get a Cabinet seat outside a coalition with the Social Democrats? Will the UK Liberal Democrats ever get a Cabinet seat except in coalition?

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by yatac42 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:50AM (#25761341)
> At this point, does any major European country have more than two viable parties or coalitions?

If we look at the coalitions that have happened at the national level in this century, we have:

* Social Democrats + Greens

* Conservatives + Social Democrats (like, a lot)

* Conservatives + Liberals

So that's three different coalitions that have actually happened in the last 20 years. Admittedly three is not a lot more than two, but it is more (and we're talking about a time frame that only includes 5 national elections and only about actual coalitions, not potentially viable ones).

And if you look at state governments as well, there are actually a lot more combinations that seem to work.

> Will the German Greens ever get a Cabinet seat outside a coalition with the Social Democrats?

Almost certainly.

At the state level they already have. In one case they're even the majority with the conservatives being the minority partner in the coalition.

At the national level they almost did in 2017. Negotiations between the conservatives, the greens and the liberals failed because the liberals backed out and the greens + conservatives didn't have a majority on their own - they would have been ready to go otherwise. It is entirely possible, even likely, that we will see a conservative-green coalition after this year's elections.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by watwut on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:41AM (#25761270)
Germany 1870 was not democracy. Germany was democracy in between 1918-1932 and it was forced to become one by their own enemies.

The incivility after 1918 was result of loosing war, result of anti-monarchy revolution, result of communist attempt for revolution and so on. It also had to do with rejection of democracy on principle. It had less to do with multiple parties existing or lack of two party system.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by jokethrowaway on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @06:47AM (#25760889)
I disagree, even with multiple parties there is always a Right vs Left battle - or better "If you don't think like me then you're the enemy".

If you're outside of those boxes you'll be attacked by both left and right wing people, to varying degrees.

I think it's an education problem, people don't understand the basics of politics or economics. They don't understand that Stalin and Hitler were both crazy authoritarians and not political opposites.

The political compass is quite biased in its questioning, but people are often surprised to hear there are more dimensions https://www.politicalcompass.org/

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by theshrike79 on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:22AM (#25761130)
> even with multiple parties there is always a Right vs Left battle - or better "If you don't think like me then you're the enemy".

It's harder to blame someone of being "the enemy" when there is a half-dozen other parties on the other side.

Yes, there still are rivalries between left/right and authoritarian/liberal parties, but having options takes some of the edge off.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by jokethrowaway on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @04:02PM (#25767927)
I've seen this happens several times, people just group all other parties as right or left and team up with parties on their side
Re:What Is Social Cooling? by matwood on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @07:51AM (#25761362)
> Created familial rifts that probably wouldn't have happened without social media.

It's definitely part of it, but not the only reason. I know my family had plenty of familial rifts pre-social media.

Re:What Is Social Cooling? by reillyse on Wednesday January 13, 2021 @02:37AM (#25759294)
People have been falling out with their families since the dawn of time.