Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler
by chrchang523 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:34PM
(#25753168)
The issue is that the corporations are acting as the government. As you noted, Germany restricts speech more than the US for obvious historical reasons. So the fact that even their government objects to this behavior is evidence against your position, not mine.
In your linked comment, all of these governments recognize (3) as a scenario that should be governed by laws (which vary between countries).
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler
by eightysixfour on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:37PM
(#25754159)
> In your linked comment, all of these governments recognize (3) as a scenario that should be governed by laws (which vary between countries).
So why not 2? When does 2 become 3?
> As you noted, Germany restricts speech more than the US for obvious historical reasons. So the fact that even their government objects to this behavior is evidence against your position, not mine.
The German and French government objects to the US not having laws that require this behavior and leaving it in the hands of private companies, sure, and I object to the US having censorship laws and would rather private entities be able to make the decision for themselves, the direction of MORE freedom of speech.
Re:How Silicon Valley destroyed Parler
by chrchang523 on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @04:59PM
(#25754507)
If this was primarily about "[objecting] to the US not having laws that require this behavior", their emphasis would not have been on the platforms being out of line.
It would be government overreach to tell the platforms that they're required to host whatever speech is posted to them, not the other way around. As I've mentioned in other comments, there are more ways to communicate now than at any other time in history. Facebook and Twitter do not have monopolies on speech, nothing on the internet does.
See this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25750501
Where would you draw the line?