I had a look around Second Life a few years ago when it was at the height of its media coverage. And it was just filled with crap. There was nothing there except brothels and shops to sell you stupid clothes.
The most interesting thing I found was an attempted replica of San Francisco, but after riding around on a cable car for five minutes I remembered that I live near the real San Francisco.
I can't see any point in having a second life that is less interesting than my first.
That's what everyone building a virtual world has to think about: how to make the new world more appealing than the world customers already know. Most new online worlds become appealing by being more inviting communities than the generality of each user's haphazard subset of real-world meatspace. I'm enjoying Facebook much better than I expected to, because it is, well, filled mostly with my friends. I was surprised to see that the author's comments in the submitted blog post were largely about the bandwidth limitations on Second Life's graphical representation of its virtual world shown to users, rather than about the community formed there. If people like a community well enough, they will put up with a pure text interface--as I have seen in my own experience.
So the blogger's noticing that Second Life's owners would rather make money with willing users who deal with the current interface than spend a lot of money to upgrade the interface makes sense. But I'm not sure that I can agree that that is a "failure," unless the purely technical exploit of worldwide, interactive, real-time virtual reality would build some new kind of more appealing community.
Because really, who wants to pay real money to allow a bunch of polygons to get a new hat and a lapdance from a robot?
I quit SL a few years ago, because it just wasn't doing it for me, but even while I was still there, there were actually quite a few interesting communities with good design and some immersive role-play going on. You did have to look around and filter out a lot of crap to find things that were at all interesting, I grant that. But your assessment seems overly harsh.
My take at the time: Second Life might be better if the real estate were at least ten times more expensive. As it was, it felt like the Asimov's Naked Sun MMORPG, only emptier. Lots of ugly buildings, each in the center of a giant empty lot, with no real attempt to relate one building to the next -- why bother, when land was so cheap? And no people that I could find. I wandered around, even did a little flying, and then I finally found another avatar... and it was a sexbot. A very poorly programmed sexbot.
Basically, there is no compelling storyline beyond "present yourself as better looking as you are in real life." That's why vibrant virtual worlds are normally based around games, which have compelling story lines around which the social atmosphere grows, rather than simply glorified chat services (which in the opinion of many are worse than other chat services since they provide an additional unneeded function).
So I installed just for the fun of it, played 15 minutes or so. But multi-player games never appealed to me (one exception is Heroes of Might and Magic hot-seat - it's real social multiplayer as people do take turns - especially fun when this goes for more than 24 hours, and everyone is pretty much drunk, smelly, some very tired, some can't stop laughing)
I didn't feel up to putting enough time for something that probably only hardcore nerds would like though, so I didn't pursue it.