That doesn't provide a guide for how to handle cases where the truth is not clear, where there is obviously legitimate grounds for disagreement.
But it's supposed to mark one of the spectrum. Many people would say that journalism has failed badly at the end of the spectrum, by taking things that are clearly true ("it's raining") and behaving as if the skeptics deserve to be heard.
Obviously, the skeptics feel otherwise, but is that relevant and if so, how much attention should we pay it?
I'm pretty sure this has always been so.
> Obviously, the skeptics feel otherwise, but is that relevant and if so, how much attention should we pay it?
Again, this depends on your goals.
As I get closer to 60, I'm swinging more towards simply acquiring and exercising power on behalf of things I believe in.
I say this despite an ironic awareness of how much I despise a movement with opposite ideals to my own for appearing to do the same thing over the last 3-4 decades.
I think people I know have been convinced in this manner. I don't think people necessarily reflect on why they were convinced. They just know that they agree with the "rain skeptics".
I'm not convinced that giving "rain skeptics" a platform would be the right thing to do if they only make up a small percentage of the population. If they make up half the population, I have no idea.
EDIT: My experience above is probably not helped by weak moderation in debates. Moderators with a backbone would probably help in cases where "rain skeptics" are given a platform. Sadly that seems to be rare.
That depends on what your goals are.
Let's continue with the above metaphor, and assume "rain skeptics" make up half of the population.
If you want a chance of convincing them that things are more moist than would appear so -- then you get to invite their most credible voices to a stage which they agree is fairly moderated.
Not which you declare to be fair and as-unbiased-as-is-possible.
One which they agree is such. And, yes, that means both sides get to sacrifice in equal number several sacred barnyard animals.
Because if not, it doesn't matter what is true or not true. Those rain skeptics will increasingly polarize against you, to the point where you simply can not reach them at all.
If you are fine with this, then you are presumably okay with green-lighting extreme measures to "solve" the "rain skeptic problem", because that's the road the United States is on right now.