Re:Steam's login method is kinda interesting
by WorldMaker on Monday January 11, 2021 @07:53PM
(#25740764)
Also, there are plenty of reasons it might not be happening as badly elsewhere as it is happening specifically on Steam. Microsoft (and Microsoft Research) has made it very clear in recent papers that distributed password spray (where the spray is spread out over large numbers of IP addresses/countries/etc) is the number 1 issue right now in passwords, and that detection and blocking are crucial. Steam has argued in the past that such things are impossible to do at their scale. (Microsoft would argue today that their scale in Office 365/Azure AD/Microsoft Accounts has easily now dwarfed Steam's scale.) There's enough evidence today (as I already mentioned) that Steam still doesn't have those detections/blocking in place (and are relying too much on Steam Guard/2FA to keep accounts safe). (Not to get too deep into the woods of Steam criticism, but the argument may not be that it is impossible at scale but that it is impossible to prioritize it within Valve's notorious management culture.)
Re:Steam's login method is kinda interesting
by abellerose on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:39AM
(#25743218)
You could attempt contacting steam and ask if they know how many attempts have been made from different IP addresses in total for login to your account. I feel like that's really the only way to verify what you're proposing. Steam likely has logs of all the IP addresses that attempt login to whatever account.
I'm skeptical of what you're proposing because it's not hard to design a system that freezes mass random IP login attempts to an account after 'x' low number of random attempts and then only allow the past successful IP addresses to continue with a successful login. As well, as do an email verification if the password is successful but being used from a new IP address.
Re:Steam's login method is kinda interesting
by WorldMaker on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:14PM
(#25752846)
I have sent tickets to Steam asking for such corroboration. I've never gotten beyond a "don't worry Steam Guard seems to be working as intended" and general Tier 1 copy-paste responses.
Re:Steam's login method is kinda interesting
by aasasd on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @01:48AM
(#25743290)
So I figured I'd go read what's ‘password spraying’ that you mention:
> Password spray is the opposite of brute-forcing. Adversaries acquire a list of accounts and attempt to sign into all of them using a small subset of the most popular, or most likely, passwords.
(https://www.microsoft.com/security/blog/2020/04/23/protectin...)
Are you saying that your fifty-character passwords are common ones?
Re:Steam's login method is kinda interesting
by WorldMaker on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:12PM
(#25752794)
Sorry, I've been inexact in my usage of the two terms. I'll endeavor to do better.
(My account is one of the oldest accounts on the platform, predating Half-Life 2's launch, and originally accessed via dial up internet. It has several now rare collections of games and at least a couple now "impossible to buy" games. Most critically to it being "well known" to have such value, it has several of the most rare/valuable "TF2 hats", which I think is incredibly dumb and that the marketplace is a huge gambling mistake, and those were known at the time when all Steam inventories were public [oh, the spam and phishing attempts that generated back when that was public and easily accessible]. My limited regard for the marketplace and limited use of it would make it somewhat obvious if I had "sold them" in the time since inventories allowed going private.)
As for a keylogger, specifically, I would go insane if I ever had to type 50+ character passwords. The keys you will log are Ctrl and V. Sure that opens up questions to clipboard logging and/or Password Manager incursion, but as I mentioned above, I have enough reason to suggest the threat isn't that sophisticated (in part because it is just "games" and "hats"), and paranoid circumvention in place already (even beyond the ones mentioned specifically in the above comment).