News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by recursive on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:48PM (#25738811)
So is censoring good or bad? I'm confused.
Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by starkd on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:51PM (#25738881)
This is the pandora's box that has been opened up.
Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by olliej on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:58PM (#25739034)
It really hasn’t been - Twitter, fb, etc have explicit tos disallowing calls for violence, harassment, etc and have just stopped letting prominent people get away with violating those rules.
Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by tfehring on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:30PM (#25739666)
I think mirroring free speech standards under the law is probably a good starting point - i.e., censoring is bad by default, but not all speech is protected, and calls for violence and insurrection are a relevant and timely example of non-protected speech.

I'll reiterate that this should be a starting point, not necessarily a hard and fast rule - there may be more nuanced situations where the standards that are appropriate for the government are inappropriate for social networks.

There's also the question of what levels of the stack it's appropriate for any censorship to occur at. Even if censorship of a particular class of speech is appropriate in general, it may not be appropriate for an ISP specifically to conduct that censorship.

Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by j_m_b on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:57PM (#25739010)
It's all relative and very nuanced. It depends on which team you're on and whose being censored!
Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by jacobsenscott on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:58PM (#25739042)
Censoring is not good or bad. It is a tool. However, most people would consider this "bad".
Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by khyryk on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:32PM (#25739703)
Depends on how much they're paying you.
Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by snvzz on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:35PM (#25739747)
Freedom of speech has always been about allowing the people you don't like to say things you would prefer they did not.

But society is losing sight of that.

Re:Citing 'Censorship' Concerns, North Idaho ISP Blocks Face... by olliej on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:56PM (#25738981)
An ISP is a dumb pipe, that’s the other side of their having access to utility poles and use of people land for their cables.

Also the suspension/bans of individual people and groups for violating well established ToS by a private company, vs banning entire sites out of petulance with no actual grounds.

The obvious follow up is for FB, et al to block the ISP so everyone switches to a different ISP.