News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by walrus01 on Monday January 11, 2021 @04:26PM (#25737373)
For HFT purposes, it's hard to hide an intercontinental range HF antenna, particularly a directional one. I know at least 3 locations not far from the illinois CME datacenter, out in some fields, with huge yagi-uda antennas aimed at London and tokyo.
Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by PoachedSausage on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:03PM (#25739152)
I'm curious as to UK end of the link now. I would guess somewhere on the hills around London to get line of sight for a microwave link down to the city.

Having just checked the Ofcom Spectrum Information System [0], it does not appear that they could have a transmitter for the opposite direction due to the frequency allocation to MoD and Amateur. Maybe they have a contract with the shortwave broadcasters to embed trading data into their broadcasts.

[0] https://www.ofcom.org.uk/spectrum/information/spectrum-infor...

Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by cl0ckt0wer on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:13PM (#25738173)
What altitude would you have to be at to have line of site to Tokyo and London from Chicago?

They're probably aimed somewhere above and in between https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skywave

Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by jsherer on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:06PM (#25739213)
You will not usually have nor do you need line of sight for HF radio. The radio waves are reflected by the ionosphere at various angles and heights, allowing the signal to be received at many different distances at once. Radio waves at the correct frequency hit the ionosphere like stones skipping along the surface of water.
Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by tzs on Monday January 11, 2021 @08:48PM (#25741223)
Assuming the same tower height at both ends, and ignoring refraction due to the atmosphere, I get that you would need 1500 mile tall towers for Chicago to Tokyo. (I did miles rather than meters because my Google for the distance between them came back in miles and I was too lazy to convert).

For Chicago to London I get 560 mile tall towers.

Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by robocat on Monday January 11, 2021 @09:59PM (#25741701)
From Chicago ORD to Tokyo NRT is 6274 miles on great circle. Distance around world is 24901 miles.

Two towers add 1120 miles (and ignoring extra length of straight line transmission compared to great arc) then a fibre optic cable on great arc would be faster than straight line if light signal within fibre travels at > 85% of speed of light (also ignoring slowdown by atmosphere for radio).

Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by caymanjim on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:41PM (#25738684)
You'd need to be in orbit.

Edit: actually it might not be possible at all from a single point anywhere in the universe.

Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by filmfact on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:22PM (#25739516)
I just stared at a globe, and it’s possible, but not from a geostationary orbit.

Think about a hemisphere projected onto a 2d circle - you can see all points on the surface of the hemisphere on the projection.

Logically it must be possible to select a hemisphere, such that any two random points on a sphere lie on that hemisphere, and would thus be visible in the projection.

The only edge cases is two points that are diametrically opposite - i.e north and south pole, which would only both be visible at infinite distance.

Points nearly diametrically opposed would only be visible from extreme distance.

This doesn’t take into account inconvenient mountains, but they can easily be moved.

Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by zaarn on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @08:48AM (#25746786)
If the two points you select on the sphere are poles of eachother (ie, their distance through the sphere is equal to the sphere's diameter, then you need to have an infinite distance from the sphere.

What you're looking for is a triangle between the two points and a third point forming your observer. The two points are visible at the same time if the derivative of the sphere's surface and the side of the triangle between a point form a positive angle (the derivative intersects the triangle at a point other than the points).

So the question then becomes "if the two points are poles, what does that mean"; easy, if the two points are poles and they're only visible if the surface derivative is within the triangle, the angle between the observer, the point and the other point must be 90°. This must hold for both points as the solution is symmetric. However, there is no well defined triangle that has two angles of 90° inside.

So the solution is "doesn't work" (or possibly infinite distance).

Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by caymanjim on Tuesday January 12, 2021 @03:11AM (#25743781)
In this case I was considering three points, but yeah, they're all in the northern hemisphere, so your scenario applies.
Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by ardy42 on Monday January 11, 2021 @05:31PM (#25738497)
> For HFT purposes, it's hard to hide an intercontinental range HF antenna, particularly a directional one. I know at least 3 locations not far from the illinois CME datacenter, out in some fields, with huge yagi-uda antennas aimed at London and tokyo.

Got any pictures?

Re:Intruder at the top of the 20 meter amateur band? by walrus01 on Monday January 11, 2021 @06:06PM (#25739208)
https://hackaday.com/2018/05/12/hft-on-hf-you-cant-beat-it-f...

With more traditional microwave for the last hop.