Re:Poll: Do you agree with Amazon, Apple and Google cutting ...
by spankalee on Monday January 11, 2021 @01:36PM
(#25733682)
This isn't "things that aren't exactly popular". This is organizing an insurrection against the government and advocating for violence against groups and individuals.
Re:Poll: Do you agree with Amazon, Apple and Google cutting ...
by xvector on Monday January 11, 2021 @01:39PM
(#25733784)
And Twitter hosts leaders of terroristic regimes. It remains unbanned. What, exactly, is your point?
Re:Poll: Do you agree with Amazon, Apple and Google cutting ...
by newfeatureok on Monday January 11, 2021 @01:38PM
(#25733742)
I understand, but that doesn't really have to do with the point I'm trying to make. Even if you use "organizing an insurrection against the government" as your baseline - is a single post on Facebook/Twitter enough to justify banning? Obviously not - the question is what metrics are acceptable given a certain level of capability by the forum/company.
Only so much moderation is possible given a certain amount of moderators and company resources. Are these rules inherently biased against smaller companies?
Re:Poll: Do you agree with Amazon, Apple and Google cutting ...
by spankalee on Monday January 11, 2021 @01:43PM
(#25733885)
What "single" post are you talking about?
Parler had thousands of offending posts and users and refused to moderate at all after being told to to be in compliance with various ToS.
It's no surprise that Amazon, Apple, Google, Twilio, etc., do not want to be associated with or support violent seditionists.
Re:Poll: Do you agree with Amazon, Apple and Google cutting ...
by shiburizu on Monday January 11, 2021 @01:50PM
(#25734059)
Whatever metric you need to hit to be linked to a group of people who rioted in the capitol building of a superpower state I presume.
Re:Poll: Do you agree with Amazon, Apple and Google cutting ...
by fooey on Monday January 11, 2021 @01:39PM
(#25733765)
Parler got deplatformed more for a refusal to moderate than an inability to moderate.
They explicitly chose to retain the content
Re:Poll: Do you agree with Amazon, Apple and Google cutting ...
by anigbrowl on Monday January 11, 2021 @02:17PM
(#25734634)
If you want to operate a social network (and can spin up to arbitrary user loads thanks to the magic of containers and cloud services), then you need to consider the possibility that your site might get jacked by a set of very difficult users.
Unfair to smaller firms? Maybe, but the phrase 'don't bite off more than you can chew' comes to mind.
Suppose you're a single-person startup of an app called "Speak!". Speak! is pretty niche, but one day, a group of the X-People are ostracized on all the popular forums: Reddit, Twitter, Facebook, etc.
Because Speak! is the only remaining bastion for the X-People all of them flock to Speak!. Let's say the X-People say things that aren't exactly popular among those who are not X-People.
BigCo claims that Speak! is not properly moderated. You say that you're only a single person and a certain level of moderation cannot be expected given N number of employees.
If BigCo bans Speak! on the grounds that Speak! is not sufficiently moderated, would that mean that any small person operation who operates a surprisingly large userbase cannot operate?
I think there should be objective quantitative measures that any company can use that's applied evenly across companies. Should a company with 10,000 moderators be held to the same standard of moderation as an extremely popular forum with only a single moderator? You decide.