News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity by lionhearted on Saturday May 21, 2011 @04:15PM (#2571642)
> Of course you enjoy it. It makes you feel smart.

You know what's funny? I think this is exactly what the author would call a "stupid" remark - it's meant to say something nasty about the person you're replying to, and you don't even gain from it!

You see, the irony here is that the author isn't actually talking about stupidity and intelligence. He's actually talking about people who engage in lose/win, win/win, lose/lose, or win/lose behavior.

He calls those "helpless", "intelligent", "stupid", and "bandit" - but normal definitions of stupidity and intelligence don't really apply, as he notes that Nobel laureates often engage in stupid (lose/lose) behavior, despite being intelligent under normal definitions.

Your comment here? It's a pretty good example of lose/lose behavior - it's designed to be a bit of a jerk towards me and makes you look snarky in the process. Lose/lose. So yeah dude, stop doing that ;)

Re:The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity by mcantor on Saturday May 21, 2011 @06:26PM (#2571915)
Maybe I'm just an optimist, but it didn't actually seem to me like he was trying to say anything nasty about you. I thought he was just joking/reflecting on the universal appeal of the article--it's well-written and accessible, so it would make most readers feel smart, and everyone likes feeling smart.
Re:The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity by arctangent on Saturday May 21, 2011 @07:01PM (#2571996)
If we could see how many votes each of the comments got we'd know who had done better out of the exchange :-)
Re:The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity by whimsy on Sunday May 22, 2011 @01:55AM (#2572749)
Winning an appeal to the populous does not imply correctness.
Re:The Basic Laws of Human Stupidity by Helianthus on Saturday May 21, 2011 @06:29PM (#2571922)
>You know what's funny? I think this is exactly what the author would call a "stupid" remark - it's meant to say something nasty about the person you're replying to, and you don't even gain from it!

Or it's meant to point out something that I, at least, happen to agree with. Reveling in identifying stupidity tends to obscure that we're all stupid at one point or another. Besides, it's not all too difficult to turn this around on you; you just called him stupid for no gain of your own.

>You see, the irony here is that the author isn't actually talking about stupidity and intelligence. He's actually talking about people who engage in lose/win, win/win, lose/lose, or win/lose behavior.

Then he shouldn't use those terms over and over again in such a misleading fashion.

All of your post--which is essentially a smokescreen--fails to address the salient accusation, which is that applying mathy and logic-y terms to a discussion of stupidity doesn't quite ameliorate the distasteful sense that, in reading/enjoying the article, we're gloating.