News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by Thorentis on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:03PM (#25704713)
Such a system only benefits the exact people and companies which we don't want abusing the copyright system. Why would Disney bother paying their lawyers millions of dollars to lobby for another extension when they can pay a small (comparative to royalties they receive) fee to automatically have it extended?
Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by pavlov on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:27PM (#25704952)
The difference is that the renewal fee is a real tax on IP, whereas Disney paying lawyers mostly benefits lawyers.

I don’t mind if Disney still owns “Snow White” a century from now, if they’re paying a $100M tax to do so.

Such a fee on each copyrighted work is a huge burden even for a large corporation. They’d choose carefully what they want to retain.

Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by anothernewdude on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:21PM (#25709937)
Disney doesn't own Snow White, it's a public domain story: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snow_White
Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by Aloha on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:46PM (#25710237)
I don't care if Disney still owns their rendition of Snow White 100 years from now, so long as they're paying 100m a year for the privilege.
Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by dstick on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:11PM (#25704789)
Agreed, even if you add two 0’s to that number, it would still benefit Disney (et al), and skew the system negatively for smaller content creators.
Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by colejohnson66 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @07:00PM (#25706553)
Disney would benefit, but if their cost doubles each year, would it be worth it? Given the formula:

    / 0              (n < 20)
    \ 10000*2^(n-20) (n >= 20)
When 'n' reaches 30 (years) you’re already looking at ~$10 million dollars. A number like that looks like it benefits the big players, but what about 40 years? That’s ~$10.5 billion for one year. Disney’s going to have to think twice about if it’s worth it to keep paying. Add another 5 years, and now they’d be paying a third of a trillion dollars for one year. I don’t think they’d even reach that point before dropping it.

The big problem with copyright is that some things don’t make sense to have copyrighted for 20 years, but some do (depending on who you ask, this may not be true). This becomes a problem when multi-billion dollar corporations own the copyright to something. That scale of money wasn’t a thing in the late 1700s when copyright was written into the Constitution.

Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by thaumasiotes on Saturday January 09, 2021 @10:42PM (#25709425)
> This becomes a problem when multi-billion dollar corporations own the copyright to something. That scale of money wasn’t a thing in the late 1700s when copyright was written into the Constitution.

Don't be confused by the numbers; that scale of money was most definitely a thing in the 1700s. Whether you measure it in 2020 USD or bolts of cloth isn't really relevant.

Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by pavlov on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:42PM (#25705100)
Small content creators benefit almost nothing from content >20 years old anyway, rare exceptions notwithstanding. Having a real tax on the most valuable IP would be a net benefit.
Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by adrianN on Saturday January 09, 2021 @11:33PM (#25710088)
If you're a small content maker but financially rely on works you've created more than 20 years ago, you're doing something wrong. Try creating something new.
Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by cma on Saturday January 09, 2021 @05:52PM (#25705872)
You could set it up so the fee funds small grants for artists.
Re:Party Like It's 1925 on Public Domain Day by anigbrowl on Sunday January 10, 2021 @02:38AM (#25711988)
Unsure why this is being downvoted, perhaps because it sounds like socialism. But grants for artists or something like UBI are actually great.