News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NFL player IQ by position by byrneseyeview on Friday July 25, 2008 @11:35AM (#256721)
The correlation between size and intelligence is positive, because malnutrition can lower adult IQ and adult size. That correlation is a lot stronger when you control for other variables, of course.

And 'speed and intelligence' is not quite the correlation you want -- IQ correlates with mental reaction time, so smarties may be 'faster' for short distances because they get a head start.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Height_and_intelligence

(The talk page for this article is delightful, by the way)

Re:NFL player IQ by position by menloparkbum on Friday July 25, 2008 @12:57PM (#256822)
The malnutrition explanation doesn't really work in the NFL. Even the "small" players weigh 220 pounds.

Regarding size, speed and intelligence, even though they are huge, most NFL linemen will have a faster 40 than most math graduate students.

Re:NFL player IQ by position by byrneseyeview on Friday July 25, 2008 @01:29PM (#256860)
That's a good point. I somehow didn't consider it before. I guess if they're in the 99.5th percentile of size, very very few of them will have any traits that cause lower height.

I agree that at 40 they will be faster. But for short bursts of speed, or for a run that requires frequent changes of direction (e.g. because you're being chased around) the higher IQ people will have a 'speed' advantage due to mental rather than physical agility.

Re:NFL player IQ by position by ojbyrne on Friday July 25, 2008 @11:31PM (#257349)
I don't think that's true. Being "quick", which I think you're talking about, is all about strength.
Re:NFL player IQ by position by byrneseyeview on Saturday July 26, 2008 @12:39PM (#257613)
It's not, really. As Galton discovered, reaction time correlates with other kinds of intelligence.

I've read that modern tests show that some groups have a faster physical reaction speed, but a slower mental reaction speed -- e.g. the signal gets from eye to brain to hand slowly, but the hand moves fast.

Re:NFL player IQ by position by menloparkbum on Sunday July 27, 2008 @12:11AM (#258013)
The thing about football quickness and reaction time, is that it is nearly all physical reaction speed. You rarely think at all. You've just repeated in practice what you need to do so many times that once you're on the field it becomes automatic. Running backs and receivers for the most part just need to be able to get downfield really, really fast. The offensive line needs to memorize more plays and formations, so a few points higher on the Wonderlic might help them in that regard. But once you're on the field, you aren't "thinking" in the sense that most people use the term. I don't think the Wonderlic scores even figure very highly into what makes a great football player. If anything, the scores are used by the coaches and trainers as a metric for figuring out the best approaches to teach the players what to do.

note: I played tight end throughout high school. I'm a bit distraught that this infographic suggests that the offensive tackles might have been smarter than me.

Re:NFL player IQ by position by byrneseyeview on Sunday July 27, 2008 @02:33PM (#258340)
I don't mean mental reaction time in the sense of quickly weighing possible courses of action -- I mean literally the time it takes for you to register a change. The simple reaction-time experiment is to hold a ruler in front of someone, so it hangs down; they have a hand wrapped around (but not touching) the end of the ruler. You let go, they grab it, you measure how far it fell to see how fast they reacted.

The thing is, some people will start to grab it fast (high mental reaction time) and other people will actually touch it sooner (slow mental reaction time, faster physical reaction time). If you're running in a zig-zag pattern, this would mean that you would start turning faster, though other people might be able to execute a complete turn (start to finish) faster despite lower IQ.

Re:NFL player IQ by position by ojbyrne on Monday July 28, 2008 @02:02PM (#259349)
And I would guess that the larger the muscles involved, the more important physical reaction is. So if you're talking about moving your fingers (as in the ruler example), then mental reaction is going to be more important, but if you're moving your whole arm or your legs, the physical reaction is more important.
Re:NFL player IQ by position by lexlibra on Friday July 25, 2008 @12:45PM (#256810)
So cornerbacks have lower IQs because they are malnourished? That explains the IQ difference in the chart? Right ...