The current title all but forces people to make up their minds before they read the article. The original title is much less biased and serves to let people draw their own conclusion after reading the article and having all of the facts.
How would you feel if someone else submitted this instead, titled Support for the Patriot Act Weakening Among Republicans? If you read the article, you would know that this is also true.
If you want to make that point, you should submit with the original title and then comment with the additional related information that you think is constructive to the conversation about the source.
From HN Guidelines:
> You can make up a new title if you want, but if you put gratuitous editorial spin on it, the editors may rewrite it.
Anyway, if the fact that I read your title means that I am more confused after reading the article than I would have been with the normal title, it is a bad title that does not fit the article.
(all the you's are to the submitter)
Edit: Also, the title is false. It hasn't actually been extended yet, it's just heading in that direction.
That's the point, the Patriot Act specifically invented one so they could increase domestic spying by several orders of magnitude and zap away rights - all without warrants. It's the only way they could have such crazy anti-constitutional powers.
Since people can still shop at the mall while we are at war, people don't realize we are in a declared state of emergency.
People often forget that PATRIOT is an acronym and implies a declared emergency (against "terrorism"). It doesn't actually mean you are only a "patriot" if you support the bill but was designed to feel that way.
1. The Patriot Act specifically removes rights due to a declared emergency.
2. It's now extended to 14 years total.
Which part is opinion?