Re:Labels used to suppress ideas
by cconstantine on Friday July 25, 2008 @10:21AM
(#256621)
My understanding is that downvoting is only for trolling or spam-like comments. Disagreement is good, disagreement can be healthy. A well-spoken (or even not-poorly-spoken) argument that is contrary to popular opinion should be upvoted.
If we don't allow, or punish, unpopular ideas we'll become a homogeneous mass with no new ideas.
These weren't trolling comments either, but legitimate arguments that popular opinion would probably disagree with.
If pg is really concerned about suppressed ideas, he should require that people give a response when they downvote and have a separate flag for "trolling" or "spam"-like comments.