News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sci-Hub: Scientists, Academics, Teachers and Students Pro... by kaba0 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @07:03PM (#25653087)
How can you steal something that is basically free to copy (I mean the process of copying)? It is not even the same case as with songs and movies where the actual creator may arguibly lose “something”, but the author here doesn’t even get compensation from his/her work based on journal sells. The only thing scihub does is not give additional profit to journals, while greatly enhancing the life of many many people partly those that produce the actual value as well (even those who would otherwise have access because university vpns suck), and morally the latter is the good thing to do.
Re:Sci-Hub: Scientists, Academics, Teachers and Students Pro... by ChrisLomont on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @12:25PM (#25659899)
>he author here doesn’t even get compensation from his/her work based on journal sells

Did you make that up or actually google to see if any journals pay? Because some do.

I get royalties on stuff I've personally written. Some of it is in technical books, and I've not checked, but I bet sci-hub even copies such stuff.

So care again to claim sci hub is not affecting any authors?

Finally, if an author wants his/her papers spread, it's easy to do. If an author only want their work in a certain journal, then the author can do that. Sci hub removes any author wish from the equation without author permission.

For example, there is no way for me to remove papers I wrote that sci hub has copied onto their servers (see above for an example link).

Re:Sci-Hub: Scientists, Academics, Teachers and Students Pro... by thatcat on Thursday January 07, 2021 @11:44PM (#25681604)
Most scientific articles are subsidized and the use case is writing more subsidized scientific papers. That doesn't effect you.