Sure, if free speech is only about speaking, then someone can speak just as well on a mountaintop as they can in downtown Boston. But speech also has an element of being heard.
When the First Amendment was ratified, speech in a public square was the commonplace way of getting a message out to the world. Now, that commonplace medium is controlled by private corporations that don't fall under the jurisdiction of the First Amendment. If "free speech" continues to be important, then we need to create additional protections for speech in these virtual public squares where people can be heard, not just for speech in Internet wastelands that are the digital equivalent of an ice floe in Antarctica.
First of all, there's no geography on the internet. Being able to only speak from the top of a mountain in Colorado in 1789 would have severely limited the potential of the population to hear you (essentially, to zero). Being able to speak "only" from one's own blog only makes discovery difficult, it does not limit people's access post-discovery.
Secondly: you appear to consider FB/Twitter etc. to be "virtual public squares". They demonstrably are not this. At the very least, it would require legislation to make them so.
Thirdly: even given the 1st amendment, even physical public squares have distinct limitations in how they can be used. For one thing, they do have geography. Any given public square is a long way from most of the population in a country of any size (even more so in countries like the USA that span thousands of miles), meaning that a particular public square is not effectively accessible to most people. As a corollary, most of the public will never be present in any actual public square.
They also have geometry: there are limits to how many people can speak in them at once.
Finally, in a public square you still cannot do the equivalent of yelling "fire" in a crowded theater, along with presence of simple noise limits for many possible public square locations. These things work very differently, or are non-existent, for written communications.
Exactly. And furthermore, while the big social media platforms help discovery and amplification, they're not that powerful (fortunately). They're not the difference between Faneuil Hall and a remote mountaintop. Posting on Facebook and Twitter is no guarantee of being heard. You can ignore all the major social media platforms and your ability to reach a wide audience is still incredibly democratized.
Yes, that is what I am saying. I am advocating for legislation to protect free speech on platforms like FB and Twitter in a similar (but not identical) way that the First Amendment protects free speech on a public street.
No it wasn't. If you wanted wide distribution of getting a message out to the world (or even wider than your literal public square), you needed it to be published & distributed. That means you had convince a publisher (i.e. a private corporation) to print your pamphlet or have the means to buy your own press. You also had to physically get it into people's hands. The Internet reduces these costs so that making your thoughts available to anyone is easier today than it ever was.
Even if it was, that still doesn't show any implied intention (it certainly is not explicit) of some right for one's speech to be heard. Enforcing such a right would be impossible and probably contradictory to some other freedoms granted in the bill of rights.
Facebook is a roped-off section at the edge of the public square. Most people who visit the public square spend most of their time in this roped-off Facebook section.
In the Facebook section, Facebook concierges monitor each person carefully. The concierge will occasionally bring various third-parties up to each person while constantly gauging engagement as a proxy for how likely a person is to return to Facebook section.
Facebook uses their engagement metric (plus all of the observations taken to derive the engagement) to value and sell access to (through the concierge) their patrons.
You are equating some specific consequences of this concierge service to censorship as if that is the only problem. This censorship is not the only problem it is also not even a relevant problem.
That’s not the same as saying they should censor, at least not censor in such a way as to effect the public discourse. They have the choice, that does not mean we can only uncritically observe their choices. If they don’t want porn, fine, which is probably a good call because it makes moderating porn a lot easier if you just ban it all, and some forms are illegal and immoral. If they want to ban pictures with the color purple or somebody holding up their hands making an “OK” gesture? That’s a bit more controversial, they can, their servers, their property, that doesn’t make it less stupid were they to do so.
There’s a million alternatives to Facebook and Twitter, tons of social media companies, the goddamned phone system, FaceTime, most chat apps, the bloody pub when the pubs are open again. This does not mean Facebook, Twitter et al. are beyond reproach in their policies, and this is why they walk such a fine line: they’re taking it from both ends.
Customers and users have a right to ask for what they want, more censorship, less, none at all or an extreme moral panic amount, maybe every post should be pre-approved by the Facebook Thought Security & Public Morals Maintenance Bureau before it goes live? I wouldn’t advocate for it, but there’s probably someone that would prefer it and deserves a slap in the head for it.
But this is the result of a complex intersection of factors, particularly contemporary journalistic practice. It doesn't just come down to their existence or size. The fact that journalists in the media that still gets the most "views" consider these platforms to be a way of "taking the temperature" of the country has at least as much to do with the way they "drive the national conversation" as anything else.
Look, I'm 100% fine with actually taking over these platforms, making them public spaces, removing all "censorship" of any kind (it would be actual censorship now, since it would done by the government), and watching them all deteriorate into an even greater stinking mess than they are already.
But I'm not fine with telling privately owned platforms what they can and cannot do, or with conflating their attempts to regulate what happens on their platforms with censorship (even in double quotes), or pretending that it matters all that much.
Meanwhile, I can still read Stratechery.
>drive the national conversation and consciousness
I honestly don't see that.
This is the important catch that the article seems to miss completely.
More specifically, it ignores the way engagement-driven distribution affects communication in the FB/Twitter mega-silos.
In a world where, say, 3 large companies can decide to change the dominant narrative that 70% of the country reads, what those three companies decide is in fact a significant social issue. It may not be "censorship", exactly, but it's still a relevant issue.
One can argue that this is a bad situation without simultaneously arguing that the platforms' limits on speech is socially important. One can argue for expanding the platform choices and reducing the manipulation->addiction games, and still be working towards a more expansive context for free speech.
So, yeah, I could go for that. More choices, less addictive, each platform carries whatever they want.
When I hear friends and families share conspiracy theories with me and I read that many people are deeply hesitant to become vaccinated, they cite these instances of YT or FB squashing posts as further proof of the legitimacy. All this is to say that these tech companies simply should not get themselves involved with answering the question of "what is true?".
I suspect that disinformation spreads faster on FB/YT/Twitter than information because it is sensational. Humans love to hear stories and are compelled by them more than facts. I second Ben Thompson here that we should focus on learning how to learn and how to parse information. We should learn how to tell when an argument is bifurcated or someone is appealing to ad populum and learn to accept nuance and disagree respectfully.
This is an idea I continually see presented as a solution. What I have not seen is an executable solution or a provable hypothesis that it is feasible.
By no means do I think it's a bad idea. But how do you execute on such an idea?
It is in those fertile grounds that intentional education, mentorship and friendship can help cure the ills. When I hear that we are year-over-year distrusting our neighbors and citizens in deep-red or deep-blue states to do the right thing, we have to learn how to trust again and see each other.
It is going to be local. And it is going to be constructive, not destructive.
Yes, absolutely.
But from my perspective this has nothing to do with the idea of whether Twitter telling you that you cannot post, or flagging your post, is a socially-significant issue that should be considered as some kind of censorship.
With limited exceptions, I'm against removal of speech as the verb "censor" is defined here: https://dictionary.cambridge.org/us/dictionary/english/censo...
On FB I've seen warnings added to the bottom of posts, and on Twitter I've seen clickthrough warnings. I think they have every right to do so. What type of content do they go all the way and remove?
Ordinary people (i.e. non-tech-nerds) are not going to abandon the large platforms for smaller ones, or federated ones. The huge amount of easily discoverable content large platforms are the reason the audience remains.
So yes, what the large information outlets does matter more than what the small ones do.
Yes, there's a network effect. No, it's not everlasting, or all-encompassing.
Basing current policy on claims about how people will behave in the future seems like a bad idea to me.
But where is the new Usenet for example? Where do you announce new software without using GitHub or Reddit or conferences for marketing?
Search engines don't find it. Torvalds had it easy with announcing Linux.
Good luck building an audience from scratch without having a strong social media presence.
Additionally, your blog can absolutely be "taken down" or canceled, even if through self preservation. Just look at SSC.
Most hosting services have very permissive policies (they have to, they could not possibly preemptively police stuff running in VMs). If you need something more permissive, find an even more permissive hosting service (probably outside the US). I'm not saying that you do anything with a blog and be guaranteed that it stayed available, but you'd have to do way, way, way more than anything a platform like FB/Twitter would take action on.
It seems to me that suggesting that this "takedown" has anything remotely to do with what is being discussed here is disingenous.
What "seems to you" is entirely wrong, but I'm curious as to how you would rationalize dismissing that as "disingenuous"[1] without even attempting to explain how. It seems like you couldn't find a way to actually reject its obvious relevancy, so you chose just not to do it by using a word that seemed like it should be enough to shut down discussion, and leave it at that.
[1]: I'm not entirely sure how the other person was "pretending to know less" by bringing up how SSC had to be taken down because in today's climate, what what was almost done to the author would have threatened his livelihood. It's a quite apt counterpoint to your notion that owning your own domain is some sort of magical protection against censorship.
Would you still believe "you don't have to interact with Supercorp?" If so, the same is true trivially with a government as well. It's very easy to leave the United States if you want. Even if you couldn't leave, you don't have to speak. After all, you have the right to remain silent.
That aside, you would think a sensible government would prevent a private entity from reaching the heights of its abilities in any area.
>the default is to push for censorship, if not by the government — thanks to that pesky First Amendment — then instead by private corporations.
It's the goddam internet. You don't have to write on FB. You don't have to write on Twitter (and please don't try to actually write on Twitter). Dozens of companies will offer you essentially one-click wordpress installations for you, with 10 more clicks to customize it to match your aesthetic inclinations. Write your stuff there .... oh wait, just like Stratechery does.
Nobody is coming for your blog. And, in the foreseeable future, nobody will come for your blog. You can write whatever you want. Getting people to read it might be slightly harder than if you use some corporatist social media platform, but arguing along those lines merely cements those platforms in their pseudo-monopolist places, which is hardly desirable for all manner of reasons.
Is it a good thing that FB/Twitter et al. can make wrong-headed decisions about the content they allow on their platforms? It's not great. But compared to the information overload issues mentioned here by other commenters, it's not obviously bad either. And it does nothing to reduce your freedom of speech.
Ben Thompson could post articles on Stratechery that make non-libellous false claims about anything he wants, and nobody will stop him. He could this every day for the rest of his life and nobody will stop him. He doesn't like the monopolistic aspects of current social media giants, but continues to insist that they are so important that any "censorship" on these platforms is a significant social issue. I find this contradictory, and naive, and in almost every sense, simply wrong.