News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Math Teaching: Lockhart's Lament by ars on Friday July 25, 2008 @04:41AM (#256415)
This lament applies to ALL the subjects in school, not just math. The problem is you just can't teach the joy of each one of these subjects to each of the students.

Some students will enjoy certain subjects and just 'get it'. But most won't, and I do not think there is any to teach it. You just can't.

So you teach what you can: at least they can read, even if they don't understand literature. Same for math: at least they can manipulate the symbols.

And the proof of the problem is the "new math". It tries very hard to do what he is saying and it's been a failure. At the end of it students don't know how to do math.

Except for those students who excel at math - but they would excel at it no matter how it was taught.

Re:On Math Teaching: Lockhart's Lament by Retric on Friday July 25, 2008 @10:54AM (#256668)
There is a stunning gap in basic capability between the best worst students, but even within subjects there are large ranges. I found Calculus II in collage a lot easer than mesmerizing multiplication tables in 2nd grade.

Many people say they hate math but love logic puzzles like SUDOKU which is math but not the type of thing they learn in school. The important thing is to not confuse students that learning the basic tools like addition and spelling have anything to do with the type of work you do as an engineer or writer. The way the system works you need to have a wide range of basically irrelevant skills before they are willing to teach real math the gray areas of history. Grouping writing poetry in the same subject as grammar is probably harmful because teachers spend so much time on grammar they the skip poetry because it's to "advanced" and it's not on the tests etc. Yet, they don't build off of each other and many of the greatest poets lived before grammar or spelling rules where written down.

PS: I expect most students would pay more attention to the basics if I they had some use for them.

Re:On Math Teaching: Lockhart's Lament by donw on Friday July 25, 2008 @11:26AM (#256710)
I think that 'finding some use for them' is an ultimately doomed approach, if only because each student is going to have different ways in which they want to use the mathematical tools with which they are presented.

My father, who is an 'educator', seems to think that the best way to learn trigonometry is to use it to teach carpentry, but I can't think of anything that would be more dull, for several reasons. One, because I imagine that well less than half of the class would have a genuine interest in carpentry; and Two, because building things with wood requires very little trigonometric calculation, so nearly all of the examples would be highly contrived.

Re:On Math Teaching: Lockhart's Lament by Retric on Friday July 25, 2008 @11:54AM (#256747)
Trig is useless. There is about 2weeks of useful math and the rest is a waste of time. People like putting trig on tests but the basic 4 year HS math program should be:

Logic + Algebra I, Geometry with a touch of number theory and topology, Grab Bag (1 year including the useful parts of Algebra II, Trig, and pre Calculus), Calculus I.

Re:On Math Teaching: Lockhart's Lament by biohacker42 on Friday July 25, 2008 @09:59AM (#256598)
Bingo! School is not really about imparting knowledge.

It's a place to keep kids, teach conformity and a very basic level of text and math comprehension, that's all there is to it.