News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by KirillPanov on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:15AM (#25628826)
> safe, walkable urban

"Walkable" is an incredibly loaded term. It has evolved to mean "convenient" rather than "has sidewalks".

Struggling creatives don't usually live in neighborhoods that are safe or "walkable", though they may be urban and have sidewalks.

Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by naravara on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:49AM (#25628986)
“Walkable” has never meant “has sidewalks.” It means the neighborhood’s denizens can reasonably walk to meet their day-to-day necessities. It has always meant that.
Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by pjc50 on Monday January 04, 2021 @08:07AM (#25630793)
This seems like a bizarre argument, surely it's an "and". Sidewalks are a necessary but not sufficient condition for walkability.
Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by mauvehaus on Monday January 04, 2021 @08:34AM (#25631080)
They really aren't. Sufficiently slow traffic (or none at all) will render streets walkable. Prioritizing pedestrian use over vehicle use is what creates walkability.

In the US you tend to find this in places that were built before cars but with sufficiently high property values that rearranging the buildings to widen the streets doesn't make sense. See parts of Boston for example. The places that are both old and wealthy tend to have streets that are pretty much local access only through size alone.

Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by graeme on Monday January 04, 2021 @09:06AM (#25631467)
In a dense enough place with narrow streets you can just walk on the road. A lot of old towns are like this.

In montreal there is an extensive system of back lanes, and I did a lot of my walking there, no sidewalks. The lanes were shared by cars but they were slow and infrequent.

Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by amake on Monday January 04, 2021 @08:35AM (#25631096)
Residential neighborhoods in the Tokyo metro area are generally walkable but have very few sidewalks.
Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by KirillPanov on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:36AM (#25629629)
> “Walkable” has never meant “has sidewalks.”

Nonsense. Interstate Highway 90 is quite unwalkable due to its lack of sidewalks.

Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by detaro on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:39AM (#25629646)
And if it had sidewalks it still wouldn't mean "[that] the neighborhood’s denizens can reasonably walk to meet their day-to-day necessities". (And in reverse, an interstate without sidewalks can be part of a walkable neighborhood if other infrastructure compensates for it)
Re:Letting Go of Nostalgia Urbanism by KirillPanov on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:53AM (#25629726)
> ... still wouldn't be a walkable neighborhood

You clearly have not seen some of the highway interchanges in Olympia, WA.

They aren't just neighborhoods, they're whole towns. Of tents. Walkable, but surely not safe.

;)