News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ignoramous on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:05AM (#25628758)
Singapore is a surveillance state. Don't be fooled by its corporate friendliness and general societal progress.

The government is every bit authoritarian which at this point increasingly looks like a euphemism for totalitarian.

https://www.aristeon.net/2019/04/singapore-as-pioneer-of-cap...

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by mparramon on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:10AM (#25628790)
>Singapore’s parliamentary political system has been dominated by the ruling People’s Action Party (PAP) and the family of current prime minister Lee Hsien Loong since 1959. The electoral and legal framework that the PAP has constructed allows for some political pluralism, but it constrains the growth of credible opposition parties and limits freedoms of expression, assembly, and association.

https://freedomhouse.org/country/singapore/freedom-world/202...

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by gbtw on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:27AM (#25628879)
And this article written by William Gibson is still relevant all these years later: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disneyland_with_the_Death_Pena...
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by iridium_core on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:46AM (#25628965)
Singapore also has one of the lowest fertility rates in the world, at only 1.16 children per woman. Living in a controlled and apartment-dominated country seems to crush the desire and ability to have many children.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by howlgarnish on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:34AM (#25629223)
I suspect the fact that it's very densely populated and extremely expensive to live in has more to do with it. Couples can generally only afford to move out into their own apartments in their thirties, and the ancillary costs of schooling (tuition etc) if you want your kids to succeed rack up so fast that few can afford more than 1 or 2.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ValentineC on Monday January 04, 2021 @09:22AM (#25631644)
> Couples can generally only afford to move out into their own apartments in their thirties

It's also a cultural thing. Most people can afford to rent in their twenties, but plenty of families discourage it.

Subsidised public housing is available to married couples, and to singles 35 and above — but the wait time for new public housing with a 99-year lease is 3-4 years [1], which probably also affects the birth rate.

[1] https://www.hdb.gov.sg/cs/infoweb/about-us/news-and-publicat...

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ClumsyPilot on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:29AM (#25629585)
Why did you choose those two variables out of dozens of others?

If it's 'control' then why is birthrate high in many dictatorships? If it's apartments, why is birthrate decent in many ex-soviet countries full of apartments?

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by read_if_gay_ on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:48AM (#25629702)
Lack of birth control maybe? Or relatively uneducated women?
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by f6v on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:56AM (#25629018)
Correlation != causation. I expected HN readers to know that.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by read_if_gay_ on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:03AM (#25629051)
GP said it seems, and just because correlation doesn't imply causation doesn't mean everything that correlates literally cannot have a causal relationship.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by Twisol on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:08AM (#25629074)
In other words... just because there's a correlation between things being correlated and things not being causally related, that doesn't mean that correlation causally implies acausality?
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by f6v on Monday January 04, 2021 @10:43AM (#25632738)
The default mode when operating with data is to assume there’s no causation. Doing otherwise creates room for too many misconceptions and erroneous interpretations.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by read_if_gay_ on Monday January 04, 2021 @11:41AM (#25633752)
Clearly you can make a hypothesis though.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by jesterson on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:16AM (#25628831)
Corporate friendliness is not a disguise. It's needed to sustain the surveillance state cashflow.

As for general societal progress, I am really not sure what are you talking about. There is no progress whatsoever.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ekianjo on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:23AM (#25628859)
> There is no progress whatsoever.

Economic progress is a thing. https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/singapore/overview

> Singapore is a high-income economy with a gross national income of US$54,530 per capita, as of 2017. The country provides one of the world’s most business-friendly regulatory environment for local entrepreneurs and is ranked among the world’s most competitive economies.

> In the decades after independence, Singapore rapidly developed from a low-income country to a high-income country. GDP growth in the city-state has been amongst the world’s highest, at an average of 7.7% since independence and topping 9.2% in the first 25 years.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by jesterson on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:32AM (#25628903)
It is, but original commenter was referring to societal progress which I found interesting.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by f6v on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:58AM (#25629028)
Never been to Singapore, but if there’s really low crime rate and people don’t litter on the streets - I’d call that progress.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by kbar13 on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:05AM (#25629062)
i dont understand this focus on litter on the streets. yes clean streets is wonderful but i dont rank it anywhere near freedom of speech and social equality or something like standardized healthcare in importance.

my hunch is that "clean streets" is mostly important to those who are not sensitive to social injustice...

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by michaelt on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:01AM (#25629396)
If you start from the proposition that the state implements the will of the people and the state's laws are just and true, then a strong state is a just state.

After all, if you can't enforce anti-littering laws, how can you hope to enforce anti-discrimination laws? To be effective at convert the law's promises into reality is a good thing, if the laws are a good thing.

Of course, I don't accept the proposition and I don't think anyone else does either - otherwise lawmakers would all have retired because their work was done.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by f6v on Monday January 04, 2021 @10:40AM (#25632692)
Yeah well, people have different priorities.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by jesterson on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:08AM (#25629075)
If you'd stay here for a while, you'd understand why there is low crime rate and no litter on the street. What even probably surprise you more is why it's happening and what it has to do with progress. Short answer - nothing.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by f6v on Monday January 04, 2021 @10:41AM (#25632719)
I can’t argue with you cause I don’t live there. But everywhere I live people complain and say government isn’t doing anything.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ValentineC on Monday January 04, 2021 @09:44AM (#25631901)
Singaporean here. There's low violent crime, but I wouldn't suggest that people leave their wallets and phones around in a public area.

Some people still litter on the streets, and it's shameful if one gets caught by law enforcement [1]. Singapore hires lots of cleaners to clean it up. We're nowhere as gracious as the residents of Japan or Taiwan.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corrective_work_order

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ekianjo on Monday January 04, 2021 @12:43PM (#25634992)
> We're nowhere as gracious as the residents of Japan or Taiwan.

I don't know enough about Taiwan to comment, but the 'cleanliness' of Japanese is exaggerated in many ways:

1) there's a very large population of smokers and I see them everyday throwing their cigarette butts on the streets.

2) yes, Japanese tend to be quite clean when people are looking (social pressure). However, go in places where nobody's there or nobody's watching, like mountains, and you will see massive amounts of litter dropped by hikers. Go on a beach that's not too frequented, and find out someone did a barbecue party the night before and left all their trash behind. Come back from a firework at night and watch your step as you walk on thousands of plastic bento boxes dropped on the floor after consumption.

So, let's tone down the myths a little.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by baybal2 on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:36AM (#25628926)
Can attest this being not the case, unless you are a bank, and can hire gazillion of local barristers to keep up with frequently changing regulatory theatrics.

For example, labour laws are faaar from what people imagine of Singapores ultracapitalist image.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by code_sloth on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:58AM (#25629027)
I actually have family there, and they have literally transitioned from near poverty to upper middle class in 2 decades. This was pretty widespreadc, but gradually becoming forgotten as the younger generations grow up in comforts that their precessors never knew.

A lot of this is due to their education system. It can be outright propaganda at times, but it has proven very effective at increasing literacy nation wide.

They've also made internet access an strategic initiative. When you marry a literate population with (generally, wink wink) free access to information and a seemingly draconian government, you get a very interesting bunch of people.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by rusk on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:53AM (#25629000)
I had a friend that worked there for a few years. He was all set to come home for a holiday and management waltzed in and just told everybody holidays were suspended. He still got to come home as he was something of a special case but it was a good story for us ...

Also the legend of the bank who called a fire drill then revoked everyone’s security when they were out of the building and told them they were laid off ...

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by baybal2 on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:13AM (#25629470)
Yes, fire at will is there, on the other hand you have quite potent wrongful termination lawsuits, and a number of hiring quotas which are often enforced.

Singapore is probably the only country which would force a business to hire somebody with clinically severe mental development issues.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ValentineC on Monday January 04, 2021 @09:53AM (#25632028)
> Singapore is probably the only country which would force a business to hire somebody with clinically severe mental development issues.

On the other hand, mental conditions are heavily stigmatised in Singapore.

No government-linked company (and Singapore's sovereign wealth fund has its fingers in most large and up-and-coming companies here) would hire someone on a career track if they have a diagnosed mental condition of some sort, anxiety and depression included.

Public health insurance downplays the severity of most mental conditions, but the status quo seems to be slowly improving: https://www.tnp.sg/news/singapore/move-include-addictions-se...

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by bigiain on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:04AM (#25629054)
> Singapore is a surveillance state.

And the Australian Covid tracing app is a copy/paste from the public open sourced github repo the Singapore government shared.

I guess being part of FiveEyes makes any fantasy of me _not_ living in a surveillance state pretty lame...

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ValentineC on Monday January 04, 2021 @09:35AM (#25631810)
> And the Australian Covid tracing app is a copy/paste from the public open sourced github repo the Singapore government shared.

The GitHub repo has a "reference" implementation of the published BlueTrace protocol [1].

Encryption keys aside, it's not possible to reproduce the Singapore TraceTogether builds currently released on both the iOS and Google App stores.

[1] https://bluetrace.io/

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by asiando on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:08AM (#25629076)
Having an app per country was unnecessary to begin with. All that Google and Apple had to do is supply the UI and accept government requests to enable the system in their country.
Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by bigiain on Monday January 04, 2021 @05:19AM (#25629512)
Apple and Google’s “exposure notification” is less useful in some important ways - it isn’t capable of backtracking to find associated contacts of infections further back in the chain. Bunnie has a good blog post about that here: https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?cat=69

Apple and Google’s thing was late to the party too, both Singapore and Australia had published their apps before the in built OS exposure notification because a thing (and I’d ballpark over 90% of Android phones haven’t got OS upgrades available that let them use the Google one anyway, none of my Android devices have it, being stuck with no manufacturer support or locked down by carriers).

So Australia and Singapore pushed on with their non OS native versions of the apps, even though the Bluetooth implementation on iOS made it very unreliable if the app wasn’t running and in the foreground. (The Android version’s Bluetooth is more reliable, if just chews through battery at a very quick pace...)

The end result is almost no useful data has come out of it here: https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2020/dec/15/covid...

Just 20 “close contacts” identified, and the government stalling on freedom of information requests to find out if any active cases were identified from those.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by ValentineC on Monday January 04, 2021 @09:40AM (#25631860)
> The end result is almost no useful data has come out of it here

The article seems to blame the lack of uptake.

Singapore doesn't have this problem, having dangled further relaxation of lockdown restrictions if more of its residents downloaded the app: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/phase-3-unlikely-by-e...

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by jariel on Monday January 04, 2021 @03:28AM (#25628881)
So general societal progress and their control of covid is evil?

The 'tracking for criminal cases' is clearly a 'bad thing' but ... it's also legit democracy with excellent universal healthcare and rule of law.

... careful with the easy characterizations.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by half0wl on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:17AM (#25629127)
Any perceived "societal progress" comes at a (heavy) cost of personal liberties; the Singapore government have always "preferred" the former.

> it's also legit democracy

If your interpretation of a democracy boils down to mere voting rights and choice, then sure, it's legit. But I think we should also consider the trickle-down effects of having the same party in power ever since the government was formed. Your ethics, beliefs, judgment, and mentality determines how you vote - it's not that hard to sway the majority to your side if you are always in total control of how lives are shaped across generations.

Re:Singapore says contact tracing data may be used for crimi... by jariel on Monday January 04, 2021 @04:20PM (#25638245)
You are saying that those voters who are making choices of their own free will - are dim? (There is no voter suppression, murder of journalists or opposition after all) And consistently vote against their own best interests? Rather an Orientalist view, no?