Re:Twitter’s Shit Sandwich
by jrockway on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @09:56PM
(#2562611)
If you can't trust the 3rd party then why the hell are you logging in?
Well, you can't really trust any third parties. So, to minimize exposure, you want to trust as few of them as possible. Now, obviously the Sony incident shows us how trusting big companies is not a good idea, but in general, bigger companies are going to try harder to protect your data because they have more to lose. Your weekend project has nothing to lose if it starts spamming my Twitter followers. But I really didn't mean to bring up this particular topic; I apologize.
I'm discussing OAuth in the context of allowing applications to do stuff to your Twitter account, not to authenticate you as you. So Twitter isn't owning your users, you are merely allowing users to delegate their Twitter permissions to you on a fine-grained basis. This is nice because it allows, say, an app to read my public tweets, but not to send them. Giving an app my password means it can do anything, and all I can do is change my password (killing all legitimate apps, too) if it does Something Bad. I think we can agree that that's sub-optimal.
I personally will not use apps that require me to use a third party to create an account. I don't mind running my own OpenID server, though, or delegating it if I'm feeling lazy. I do mind being locked into someone else's platform forever.
Well, you can't really trust any third parties. So, to minimize exposure, you want to trust as few of them as possible. Now, obviously the Sony incident shows us how trusting big companies is not a good idea, but in general, bigger companies are going to try harder to protect your data because they have more to lose. Your weekend project has nothing to lose if it starts spamming my Twitter followers. But I really didn't mean to bring up this particular topic; I apologize.
I'm discussing OAuth in the context of allowing applications to do stuff to your Twitter account, not to authenticate you as you. So Twitter isn't owning your users, you are merely allowing users to delegate their Twitter permissions to you on a fine-grained basis. This is nice because it allows, say, an app to read my public tweets, but not to send them. Giving an app my password means it can do anything, and all I can do is change my password (killing all legitimate apps, too) if it does Something Bad. I think we can agree that that's sub-optimal.
I personally will not use apps that require me to use a third party to create an account. I don't mind running my own OpenID server, though, or delegating it if I'm feeling lazy. I do mind being locked into someone else's platform forever.