Re:AMD Patent Reveals Hybrid CPU-FPGA Design That Could Be E...
by imtringued on Sunday January 03, 2021 @03:40PM
(#25625021)
It's easier to provide "custom instructions" and only accelerate CPU bottlenecks if you don't have PCIe as a massive bottleneck. If you are using an accelerator behind a bus you always have to make sure there is enough work for the accelerator to justify a data transfer. GPUs are built around the idea of batching a lot of work and running it in parallel. You can make an FPGA work like that but you are throwing away the low latency benefits of FPGAs.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:AMD Patent Reveals Hybrid CPU-FPGA Design That Could Be E...
by wtallis on Sunday January 03, 2021 @05:25PM
(#25625797)
Even the best-case scenarios for integrating a FPGA onto the same die as CPU cores would still have the FPGA separate from the CPU cores. It's really not possible to make an open-ended high bandwidth low latency interface to a huge chunk of FPGA silicon part of the regular CPU core's tightly-optimized pipeline, without drastically slowing down that CPU. The sane way to use an FPGA is as a coprocessor, not grafted onto the processor core itself. Then, you're interacting with the FPGA through interfaces like memory-mapped IO whether it's on-die, on-package, or on an add-in card.
Re:AMD Patent Reveals Hybrid CPU-FPGA Design That Could Be E...
by therealcamino on Sunday January 03, 2021 @09:30PM
(#25627387)
> It's really not possible to make an open-ended high bandwidth low latency interface to a huge chunk of FPGA silicon part of the regular CPU core's tightly-optimized pipeline
That's what's interesting about the article, because that's what the patent is about: "implementing as part of a processor pipeline a reprogrammable execution unit capable of executing specialized instructions".
Re:AMD Patent Reveals Hybrid CPU-FPGA Design That Could Be E...
by Traster on Sunday January 03, 2021 @05:29PM
(#25625831)
Yeah, worth mentioning highly optimized FPGA designs run at up to 600MHz (or to put it another way, 400MHz lower than what Intel advertised 4 years ago). So at a minimum, you're going to clock cross, have a >10 cycle pipeline at CPU speeeds (variable clock) and clock cross back.