News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Societal Collapse by themodelplumber on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:24PM (#25618758)
Man, sharing this link in January 2021 is just brutal :D

It made me wonder though, who here legitimately thinks their society is nearing collapse? Which society? By which measures are you evaluating the situation?

Do you feel you have any control over the collapse, or a participation mandate at any level? How much does it seem to parallel your current personal life situation? Are things similarly chaotic, or do you find yourself at peace?

Just curious.

Re:Societal Collapse by JackMorgan on Saturday January 02, 2021 @10:05PM (#25618969)
I have a friend who is convinced that we're already mid-collapse and have been for decades. He cites many of the same causes found in the link above. He says, "just look at what happens to any wild animal when there aren't enough resources or they're stressed, they start going crazy: self harm, eating young, death by refusing to eat."

He sees echos of behavior patterns like a fractal, so tiny patterns of behaviors in mice emerge as patterns in larger human society. He has said that he thinks human societies are just another organism that lives, ages, and dies. He doesn't really prep or anything, just expects he and most people he knows to die in food riots sometime in his life. He doesn't even bother prepping (so he says) because such a collapse likely would come from a way that he can't expect and wouldn't likely survive anyway. He realizes there isn't enough ammo to hold off millions of starving people, and the people who survive likely would do so accidentally or through freak luck, but a new society would emerge again in a few generations to repeat the cycle again. Fun guy, my friend.

Re:Societal Collapse by brutusborn on Saturday January 02, 2021 @10:20PM (#25619069)
I too wonder if mental health issues are symptoms of larger problems in our society, but I am hopeful that we can figure out the mechanisms and adapt. It's difficult to study complex systems, but I have some 'faith' that we can build the tools necessary.

Some mechanisms that seem obvious to me are overpopulation and laws restricting personal freedom (e.g. laws on sexuality or laws on drug use). The 1 child policy is an example of a (failed?) attempt at addressing the 1st issue.

Re:Societal Collapse by idiocrat on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:42AM (#25619795)
The whole premise of 5% target growth per year is flawed and unsustainable. To my understanding the world's economic policies are set to spend resources to promote growth. 5% growth means doubling virtually everything every 10 years: imagine doubling energy consumption, double population in every city, double production, consumption. There is no a non-ideological answer/solution to the state of the world. The balance of nature will settle itself to an equilibrium, hopefully without too much pain and without complete destruction of the environment.
Re:Societal Collapse by brutusborn on Sunday January 03, 2021 @08:10PM (#25626926)
Where do you get 5% growth from? Is it just extrapolated from expected returns on investment?
Re:Societal Collapse by JackMorgan on Sunday January 03, 2021 @10:02PM (#25627538)
Not the original commentor, but much of the US' financial system is run with the express goal of trying to grow at about 5% per year. The target inflation of 2% is intended to encourage us to spend money reinvesting in new business rather than sitting on it. Returns have to be better than 2% to just break even.
Re:Societal Collapse by brutusborn on Monday January 04, 2021 @08:30PM (#25640868)
But where do you get this 5% figure from? My understanding was that the inflation target of 2% was to reduce the risk of runaway deflation. I'm not saying you're wrong, but I hear the "unlimited growth" argument crop up a lot with no basis.
Re:Societal Collapse by idiocrat on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:39AM (#25642526)
Really sorry for causing confusion, by putting up such an exact number, 5%. It is just my common understanding that the countries anchoring the growth goals around that number.

The policies pf cause vary by country (developed, developing), for example for GDP:

Japan's "annual forecast is +3.6% in 2021, and +2.2% in 2022". [0]

The UN's Sustainable Development Goal [1] sets "For the least developed countries, the economic target is to attain at least a 7 percent annual growth in Gross Domestic Product (GDP)."

Long time ago I remember watching a video by a prof, who asked a local council what would be the desirable growth (in range 1%-10%). The council agreed that 5% is reasonable. Here I found the video [2].

[0] https://www.ubs.com/global/en/investment-bank/in-focus/2020/...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sustainable_Development_Goal_8

[2] https://youtu.be/DZCm2QQZVYk?t=520

Re:Societal Collapse by dognotdog on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:12PM (#25619362)
Or possibly we never before in history had the wherewithal to be aware of, diagnose, and treat mental health issues to the extent we can today?
Re:Societal Collapse by brutusborn on Sunday January 03, 2021 @08:13PM (#25626943)
This is definitely possible. And we will possibly never be able to tell, since the information required is already lost to history.
Re:Societal Collapse by dougmwne on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:06PM (#25619327)
I think your friend could use some help and positive encouragement. This kind of scenario has not played out in previous famines. They are not exactly rare events in history. People would do what they could and make the best of what they have, as we have always done. Our knowledge and technology are also going to help us feed ourselves and if you need any proof of that just look at the marvelous vaccine work that has occurred in less than a year.
Re:Societal Collapse by tathougies on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:10AM (#25619654)
I mean, there have been famines in recent human history in which people have allegedly turned to cannibalism and other behavior we would consider barbaric?
Re:Societal Collapse by themodelplumber on Saturday January 02, 2021 @10:17PM (#25619044)
I wonder, has your friend looked into the "growth and change looks like death" folks? Barbara Marx Hubbard is a good example. She offered the example of butterfly metamorphosis, which involves a pretty stunning systemic breakdown at a very deep level.
Re:Societal Collapse by howlgarnish on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:14AM (#25619671)
I moved from Europe to the US as a teenager, and I remember being shocked at the evident shock, decay and poverty I saw even in what was supposed to be a large and prosperous city (New York).

It took me a long time to realize that this is how America works: things that didn't work or that nobody wants are allowed to fail, and this clearing out of the underbrush is what allows new things to come forth. Contrast this with Europe, where things like unprofitable state enterprises are propped up essentially forever, sucking away capital and people that could be doing something useful instead.

But this was a long, long time ago. These days I don't hold out much hope for the US or for Europe: humanity's future is in Asia.

Re:Societal Collapse by lcall on Sunday January 03, 2021 @03:59PM (#25625204)
I believe there will be collapses and very hard things, but we can be OK (for a long list of reasons). I've written more elsewhere (at my site). But really, if we try to learn and do what is right, with a clear conscience, we can be OK.

(Honesty and kindness are very important, as are the principles underlying the US Constitution. And more.)

Re:Societal Collapse by op03 on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:28AM (#25619745)
I have multiple ant colonies in my garden and when I was younger spent a whole lot of time trying everything imaginable to get rid of them (induce collapse you could say). But with each attempt my admiration for them just kept growing. Cause these fuckers with their spec of dust sized brains keep chugging along the next day morning as if nothing at all happened. Its like every calamity is just a minor interruption to whatever they are upto. So I just use their model. My mantra over time has become - "Dont sit around appreciating the pain. Get back to work"

But the caveat here is, as with the ants, you must have a goto list of things to do. When I was younger I had no idea what I wanted to do so the mantra worked terribly. But the older I have gotten the list of things to do has grown. So like the ant no matter what happens theres always something to do.

Re:Societal Collapse by throw0101a on Sunday January 03, 2021 @11:27AM (#25622716)
> It made me wonder though, who here legitimately thinks their society is nearing collapse? Which society? By which measures are you evaluating the situation?

Since you ask:

* https://old.reddit.com/r/collapse/

The more pratically-minded lean more towards:

* https://old.reddit.com/r/preppers/

There's a certain minimum effort that most people should probably do (even if you don't live in a earthquake zone or hurricane area)

* https://www.ready.gov

* https://www.getprepared.gc.ca/index-en.aspx

Re:Societal Collapse by jdkee on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:48PM (#25618875)
Parts of the United States resemble a failed state with endemic violence, hunger and poverty exacerbated by the pandemic.

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/02/us/crime-poverty-pandemic...

Re:Societal Collapse by zymhan on Saturday January 02, 2021 @10:23PM (#25619083)
> It made me wonder though, who here legitimately thinks their society is nearing collapse?

Indeed, it seems passive-aggressive to just post this link without any further commentary.

Re:Societal Collapse by sleepysysadmin on Monday January 04, 2021 @10:50AM (#25632840)
>It made me wonder though, who here legitimately thinks their society is nearing collapse? Which society? By which measures are you evaluating the situation?

Not exactly, but I can completely see why some people think so.

What's happening fundamentally is that the boomers are on the verge of retirement. The worker shortage of 2030 is set in stone and the only way to mitigate the damage is very large amounts of immigration.

the problem is that housing is limited, worker shortage means housing wont be built to required capacity, and our top industries are becoming parasitic at best. This creates political pressure.

Then add in the consequences, women entering the workforce has been wonderful but not for the average worker. Supply increased by demand decreased because political policy of globalism shipped jobs out of the country. Thus we have income inequality that's out of control. We also have historic lows of marriage and births.

The blame is 100% in the hands of the government. you then look at the government's failure and it's a disaster. So many federal governments are functionally bankrupt and the debt is higher than ever. the government cant afford to fix their mistakes.

What's the point of society? It's the humans. We have failed in this regard. Will it be collapse?

Nope, but I know what's coming to prevent the collapse. the governments know how to do this each time.

Re:Societal Collapse by thewarrior on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:50PM (#25618892)
I have been learning more about biology and the immune system. I’ve realized that genetic engineering of viruses is something far easier than making a nuclear weapon and could easily wipe out humanity. It doesn’t have to be a government some crazy cult might just do it 50 years from now and create a pathogen immune to most vaccines.
Re:Societal Collapse by tylerjwilk00 on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:55PM (#25618928)
You might enjoy looking at society as one large organism [1]. Many biological patterns reemerge at this scale.

Imagine the pandemic government response as a large scale societal immune response. Inner city violence as a form of inflammation...

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_organism

Re:Societal Collapse by flukus on Saturday January 02, 2021 @09:57PM (#25618935)
You don't even have to wipeout humanity, look at the financial destruction the current virus has done and consider how non-lethal it is compared to many others.

For that matter, every tinpot dictator and would be terrorist in the world could easily get their hands on this virus, store it for a few years until immunity has worn off and we don't have huge stockpiles of a vaccine, then purposefully release it in a dozen major cities at once, it would spread for a couple of weeks before being noticed.

Re:Societal Collapse by frongpik on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:27PM (#25619441)
I'll take the liberty to share some notes from unscientific sources, because I find the official sources plain boring.

A civilization is generally started by great people that put grand ideals into its foundation. A sign of such founders is their borderline unbelievable holiness, that makes them a legend. During its lifespan, great minds get replaced by small minds. The typical lifespan is about a million years, but maybe this time things move a lot quicker. The latter are attracted not to the ideals, but to the earthly things, such as shiny metals and power over others. I believe we are here now. In all cases, such people eventually discover the secret of black magic (I know, many would cough here) and the dark age begins. A sign of that phase is cyclopic brutalistic architecture that worships human body (that's an important detail). We've had a glimpse into that already: nazism. We seem to be moving rapidly in that direction: powerful dictatorships are plenty, while democracies are few. Another sign of that phase is abandoning liberty and reason, because the evil (the dark side of every human) has neither, and embracing chaos and fatalism. Example: the idea that voting doesn't matter, whether it's technically true or not. The terminal stage of every big civilization is a collapse into a sort of a black hole: people are paralyzed by fear and hate, the dominating ideology is a dark cult. There's no coming back from that stage, as that kind of dark cult has real power. At this point, the civilization always gets an external "help" that wipes everything out, so the few survivors could start it over, but now at the next level.