News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human Brain Project: $1.61 billion to achieve human brain... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @04:23PM (#2561633)
What if human consciousness is an emergent property of physical brain hardware?

edit, s/emergency/emergent

Re:Human Brain Project: $1.61 billion to achieve human brain... by ChuckMcM on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @06:37PM (#2562118)
That will be an interesting outcome. What if it's not?

Can you imagine how weird it would be if we backed into proving a universal consciousness existed in a different dimension and an exactly modelled/simulated brain didn't get to participate because it wasn't given a 'soul' by that consciousness?

Or the flip side where our brain model does develop sentience as an emergent property and the spiritualists have to deal with the possibility that they are just animated meat.

Or the creepy side where you take an imprint of your current brain state, impart it on the model and suddenly the model thinks it's you?

Science fiction has explored these concepts for a while. I know that personally I'd like there to be something "special" about consciousness and/or sentience but I am rational enough to know that this isn't backed up by solid reasoning, just wishful thinking.

In a highly networked, highly automated, world the idea that consciousness could simply 'emerge' from a sufficiently constructed system is deeply disturbing.

While much of what the film "Eagle Eye" speculated on with a sentient computer connected to everything seemed pretty bogus, the ability to disrupt and render unusable a wide range of systems simulataneously by a disgruntled AI is not an experience I would anticipate as being 'pleasant.'