News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Eight Out Of China’s Top Nine Government Officials Are Sc... by danssig on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @12:27PM (#2560669)
This is more of typical "find some way to make everyone who takes any action into a hypocrite". First of all, just because Chomsky believes something doesn't mean he has to practice it if no one else is. What would it benefit the world for him to be poor?

I have some strong Anarchistic beliefs (i.e. the immorality of one man ruling another, not the smash-things-up kind) but I do literally nothing (outside of talking) for it because it's not practical. I could only ruin my own quality of life and who would see that kind of example and say "wow, count me in!". I'm in a capitalist system so I may as well learn it and use it to the best of my abilities. It's almost certain to be the only system I ever live under no matter what actions I take.

Likewise, very few people listen to Chomsky so he may as well use the system he will live his whole life in to the best of his ability.

And finally, the messenger is different than the message. It is perfectly valid for a smoker to preach about the evils of smoking. He can even call people who smoke stupid. Him smoking doesn't make his message invalid.

Re:Eight Out Of China’s Top Nine Government Officials Are Sc... by ramanujan on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @07:47PM (#2562349)
Look, I'm not saying you're a bad guy or that working within the system for change is illegitimate.

My point is this: smoking while convincing others that smoking is bad makes you worse off but others better off. That's a failure of will.

But piling up millions in a trust while arguing that other rich people should be punitively taxed makes Chomsky better off but others worse off. That's hypocrisy.

Re:Eight Out Of China’s Top Nine Government Officials Are Sc... by danssig on Thursday May 19, 2011 @05:54AM (#2563427)
It would only be hypocrisy if he said they should be punitively taxed and he shouldn't. So long as those holes exist he would be foolish to not use them.

He's in the same situation as Warren Buffet: both condemn/ridicule the current system and both do what ever is available to them within the current system.