News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:03PM (#25600049)
I think batteries will be annihilated by fuel cells in the near future. So in all likelihood the current business of Tesla will be wiped out. Tesla could only survive if it completely reinvents itself.
Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:30PM (#25600234)
VW had a great illustration showing why fuel cells are inferior to batteries: https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1127660_battery-electri...

AFAICT, there is no metric by which a green hydrogen powered fuel cell car is superior to a BEV. It's more expensive to buy, at best is 3X as expensive to fuel, is far more inconvenient to fill up (a grand total of 39 stations in the US), lower range (300 miles for current models), and is far less reliable (hydrogen embrittlement).

That's assuming it's powered by green hydrogen (aka, hydrogen created via electrolysis). Grey hydrogen cracked from natural gas is cheaper than green hydrogen, but if you're not going green, why would you get anything other than a gasoline car?

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:35PM (#25600264)
These are backwards looking arguments. I'm talking about a future where: fuel cell cars are far cheaper, hydrogen is approximately as cheap and efficient as electricity, there is a substantial hydrogen infrastructure in place, and range is 400 miles or more (this has already happened). BTW the last statement was always wrong as modern fuel cell vehicles are more reliable than battery powered ones.

It will be green hydrogen too. I don't think anyone is seriously proposing grey hydrogen as a fuel.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by ericb on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:29PM (#25604854)
We already have electrical transport infrastructure everywhere to the last mile. Hydrogen, not so much.
Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:38PM (#25600287)
> hydrogen is approximately as cheap and efficient as electricity

This is physically impossible. Green hydrogen is created from electricity and water and is converted back to electricity and water in a fuel cell. These are both lossy processes.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:42PM (#25600299)
No more so than a battery. A fuel cell is in fact a battery of sorts, and it's not out of the question that it approaches the efficiency of a conventional battery.

It should also be pointed out that the lower weight of a fuel cell powertrain allows you to use less energy during operation. So even if fuel cells don't fully match the efficiency of conventional batteries, they can still use less energy on a final basis.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:46PM (#25600326)
Measuring power loss between electricity generation and wheels, current fuel cell cars are 25-35% efficient. Teslas are 90% efficient. (https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1127660_battery-electri...)

A Toyota Mirai weighs 1848kg. A Tesla Model 3 weighs 1612kg.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:51PM (#25600349)
It's probably closer to 40% and 75% respectively. VW is probably not being totally honest with their numbers. This gap will shrink in the future.

The Mirai is overbuilt for what it is. The Hyundai Nexo is 1814-1873 kg despite being an SUV. For reference, the Model Y is 2003 kg.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @10:11PM (#25600473)
The single motor standard range version of the Y would be about 200 kg lighter, and is a bigger vehicle than the Nexo.

The motors in the Model 3 are 97% efficient. 90% for the entire system is not a dishonest number

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Thursday December 31, 2020 @10:24PM (#25600549)
On the other hand, the Nexo is storing a much larger amount of energy. At 6.3 kg of hydrogen and at 33.3 kWh of usable energy per kg, that's 209.8 kWh. The Y only stores 75 kWh in comparison.

Fuel cells are around 60% efficient today. The system efficiency is probably around 55%. This is a number that will increase as fuel cells get more efficient. I believe the gap will eventually close altogether, or at least shrink greatly.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by rsfern on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:10AM (#25602996)
I think your focus is a bit narrow here, and physical impossibility is a really strong statement.

Advances in photocatalytic water splitting could easily make this a reality.

That said I’m under the impression that progress in battery tech is a lot more active right now, and it’s not really clear that finding an efficient and economical photocatalytic material is very realistic

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by bryanlarsen on Friday January 01, 2021 @08:42AM (#25603182)
No matter how efficient your hydrogen production is, it still has to be compressed and chilled. You can't do this without energy.
Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by rsfern on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:59PM (#25605116)
Sure, I agree with you, it seems unlikely that fuel cell tech will overtake advances in batteries in the near future, and that compressed hydrogen doesn’t seem likely to become competitive.

My point is that there are many other hydrogen generation and storage technologies at various degrees of maturity and viability, and it doesn’t seem productive to write off a potential economical fuel cell system as a physical impossibility.

I do think there are many challenging engineering problems along that path, and I’m not convinced it’s tractable at all, much less likely to outpace advances in battery systems.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:21PM (#25607312)
> I do think there are many challenging engineering problems along that path, and I’m not convinced it’s tractable at all, much less likely to outpace advances in battery systems.

I disagree on that last part. Fuel cell is moving at warp speed right now, and batteries are losing ground at a rapid rate. We're seeing fuel cells move into everything from e-bikes to aircraft. If there's any kind of disruptive event here, it will be fuel cells replacing batteries at a much faster rate than expected.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Friday January 01, 2021 @04:09PM (#25607160)
Not necessarily. You can store it in metal hydrides. It's also a small amount of energy comparatively, so it's not a big loss. Finally, you can recover a lot of the energy back.
Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by cowmix on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:07PM (#25600076)
Why do you think this?
Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:11PM (#25600105)
It's the fundamentally superior technology. It's likely to be much cheaper than batteries in the long run, and I suspect will eventually equal batteries on efficiency too (fuel cells are technically batteries themselves). We can go into elaborate details on this, but that is the gist of it.
Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by bryanlarsen on Thursday December 31, 2020 @10:25PM (#25600555)
> I suspect will eventually equal batteries on efficiency too (fuel cells are technically batteries themselves).

Fuel cell vehicles also use batteries. The fuel cell charges the batteries, and the batteries power electric motors. So it's impossible for a fuel cell vehicle to be more efficient than a battery-electric vehicle.

Not to mention the massive losses generating the hydrogen, during electrolysis and compression.

Re:Tesla Short Sellers Lost $38B in 2020 as Stock Surged by Hypx on Thursday December 31, 2020 @10:37PM (#25600612)
Not necessarily. They can use capacitors instead. And the battery is only engaged when accelerating or braking. The car runs mostly on the fuel cell in steady state operation.

Those are just assumptions. There's no reason why you can't you reduce them to the point where they are non-factors. It's possible they go away completely, for instance if you use thermochemical production of hydrogen or store hydrogen in metal hydrides.

As I said previously, you don't need to perfectly match batteries on efficiency. If fuel cells get close to batteries, it's enough for them to succeed. The rest can be made up by a combination of lower upfront costs and light weighting.