News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Questions you can't ask by Tichy on Thursday July 24, 2008 @07:00PM (#255965)
I think the issue is not whether IQ is a good predictor of success, within the system of it's application (for example the military screening new employees). The issue is whether this equates intelligence.

Rephrased: there would probably be less of an issue if it IQ was really "SP" (Success Predictor), not "Intelligence Quotient".

It might seem like the same, but I don't think it is: throw a Harvard graduate into the middle of the jungle, and he might fare rather badly. On the other hand, throw a perfectly successful jungle inhabitant into the middle of Harvard and he might also fare rather badly.

Re:Questions you can't ask by dominik on Friday July 25, 2008 @09:28AM (#256573)
On the other hand, throw a perfectly successful jungle inhabitant into the middle of Harvard and he might also fare rather badly.

To the contrary, I think the denizens of Harvard might fare badly, not the perfectly successful jungle inhabitant. Professors got nothing on panthers.

Re:Questions you can't ask by Tichy on Friday July 25, 2008 @10:09AM (#256606)
That's what I said: the professor will get eaten in the jungle, the junge inhabitant will get run over by a car in the city.

Obviously IQ tests measure something: at the very least, they measure performance on IQ tests. The controversy starts when people claim to measure "intelligence".

Might be fun to design a "jungle IQ test".