News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Google's hiring process is broken by javert on Tuesday May 17, 2011 @06:00PM (#2558106)
I guess you're saying, why didn't I just tell the other company "yes," and then reneg if Google accepted me?

For one thing, I don't like pulling crap like this.

I might have anyway, except that it would have damaged existing and longstanding relationships in the other (non-Google) company that are worth maintaining to me.

Re:Why Google's hiring process is broken by dclowd9901 on Tuesday May 17, 2011 @06:31PM (#2558212)
While your intentions are undoubtedly admirable, and you certainly more than likely have very valid reasons for not "pulling crap like this" (not burning bridges, for one), I hope you're not mistaken by some baseless belief that any company would extend you the same courtesy.
Re:Why Google's hiring process is broken by javert on Tuesday May 17, 2011 @07:15PM (#2558376)
Meh.

I think it's pretty rare for a company to tell someone "Yes, you can definitely work for us, here is a contract for you to sign and a start date and how much you're going to make" and then revoke that.

Which is the equivalent to me telling a company I'll work for them and then reneging.

But of course, yes, they could do it, and you're right that people and companies aren't always courteous.

Re:Why Google's hiring process is broken by abbasmehdi on Tuesday May 17, 2011 @11:06PM (#2558896)
I've had a company retract an offer after I asked for an extension to accept. I guess they felt like a second choice.
Re:Why Google's hiring process is broken by dclowd9901 on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @02:40PM (#2561170)
I'm glad your experiences have been so plush. In my past as a graphic designer (this doesn't happen anymore in web development, mind you), I've been hired and then let go in the span of a few months, due to cuts and layoffs. Maybe I'm burned and a bit cynical, but the lesson I've taken away is that business is business.
Re:Why Google's hiring process is broken by adnam on Wednesday May 18, 2011 @04:58PM (#2561794)
It's not "pulling crap", as you say. For one thing, until you sign the contract, you're not bound in any way. Even then, the first few months are typically defined as a trial period, in which both parties are free to walk away. Better opportunities always crop up, and you can just say "sorry, a better offer has popped up".