News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s longtime supplier accused of using forced labor i... by coldtea on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @10:19PM (#25578057)
>The US doesn't need to be perfect before US citizens can decry Religious Slave Labor Camps in China

Oh, yes, it does. Surely not perfect, but much better, or at least not as bad.

Especially since unlike China thus far, the US tends to drop bombs and invade places they "decry".

Re:Apple’s longtime supplier accused of using forced labor i... by Alupis on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @10:35PM (#25578161)
>> The US doesn't need to be perfect before US citizens can decry Religious Slave Labor Camps in China

> Oh, yes, it does. Surely not perfect, but much better, or at least not as bad.

The country that was founded on the principal of religious freedom, by people that fled religious persecution, and felt so strongly as to list religious freedom as item number one in their list of human rights, does not need to be "much better" to call out religious slave labor camps.

Re:Apple’s longtime supplier accused of using forced labor i... by coldtea on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @10:47PM (#25578249)
>The country that was founded on the principal of religious freedom, by people that fled religious persecution, and felt so strongly as to list religious freedom as item number one in their list of human rights, does not need to be "much better" to call out religious slave labor camps.

"The country that founded on the principal of religious freedom" is nationalistic trite, like "land of the free" (which ended slavery later than other western countries, gave poor, blacks, and women the vote later, has 25% of the world's prison population, and so on), and "home of the brave" (where the Army is professional and the majority of the population had never had the chance to fight in any war or suffer any war domestically for over a century, so one wonders how/what this "braveness" is measured with and against).

First, what the country was "founded on" means little. What the country has historically did and up to now does (warred, enslaved, invaded, occupied, strong-armed, intimidated, etc.) matters more.

Second, the fact that a country was founded by religious hardcores literally thrown out of Europe for being such, and that they wanted "religious freedom" in their new dwellings so as to they not kill each other, doesn't give it any special moral high ground. Heck, if it was up to any of the religious sects that ended up there, the others would be illegal (the US still has the most fundamentalist religious people in the West, which when they had the upper hand were ok with forcing their will as law on anything from abortions to music releases). But they needed "religious freedom" because none of them had the power over all the other denominations (all Christian at the time, mostly variations of protestantism), and thus they made a virtue out of necessity.

Not to mention that they still managed all together to opress the blacks (nuff said), the native americans ("trail of tears"), the early Chinese, Irish, etc immigrants, and so on...

Re:Apple’s longtime supplier accused of using forced labor i... by Alupis on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:31PM (#25585077)
So effectively you are arguing that since the US did bad things in the past, China should be allowed to imprison millions based on their religion alone?

How does this add up?

Re:Apple’s longtime supplier accused of using forced labor i... by coldtea on Thursday December 31, 2020 @02:31AM (#25590458)
No, effectively I'm arguing that the US should check its own hypocrisy before pointing fingers, especially if it does it selectively (doesn't matter when allies / we do it), hypocritically, and as part of a power play/trade war. (Also, it wasn't "in the past", the US does bad things continuously. W. Bush, Obama -more of the same-, and Trump presidencies weren't in some distant past...)

How about both China and the US stop fucking over with millions, and people don't "patriotically" only point fingers to the other, and give their home team a pass (with much less, and much tamer, criticism, whereas it should be even more vigorous, it being their own domain?).

Re:Apple’s longtime supplier accused of using forced labor i... by Alupis on Thursday December 31, 2020 @12:19PM (#25594643)
Nobody is giving the US a "pass". All of our problems are out in the open for everyone to see and comment on, US Citizens or foreigners alike! That's part of what makes the US so unique.

Regardless, no issue any country has domestically is going to excuse Religious Slave Labor Camps in China. That's wrong no matter where you live or who you are. People like to throw Hitler around too easily... but this is exactly what the Nazis did... imprison and exterminate entire populations of "undesirables" based solely on religion.

Arguing the US needs to shut it's mouth because it has some domestic issues doesn't fly...